search

t0mer / broadlinkmanager-docker

Broadlink Manager is a python based project that allows you to contorol your broadlink devices. Discover, Leran and send command in a very easy way
Apache License 2.0
259 stars 56 forks source link

Broadlink Manager Windows see invalid device, docker version sees nothing? #47

Open ZoltrixGFC opened 2 years ago

ZoltrixGFC commented 2 years ago

Hi,

I have an Broadlink RM4 Pro S. Tried both the Windows Broadlink Manager software and the docker version.

The Windows version reports: Looking for devices... Found device : Unknown [192.168.0.42] Writing compatible device not detected!

The docker version finds nothing when doing a scan.

I can confirm the docker version is setup on the same network, so unsure why it isn't picking anything up?

Any advice?

gui28347 commented 2 years ago

same problem for me, RM4 PRO and RM4 Mini

t0mer commented 2 years ago

Hi, I stopped working on the desktop version long ago. I can try add the supported devices from the docker version but I'm not sure it will work.

ZoltrixGFC commented 2 years ago

@t0mer would be great if you could add them, but why do you think it won't work?

I'm a bit stuck at the moment, as Home Assistant won't scan one of my remotes (scans others ok). I posted the issue, but no response yet: https://github.com/home-assistant/core/issues/63578#issuecomment-1007112478

rackey12 commented 2 years ago

I have the same issue i have an RM4 Mini (RM4C i think) and an S3 hub but the docker is not picking up anything

ZoltrixGFC commented 2 years ago

Yep still the same issue here.

pakshuang commented 2 years ago

Same. RM4C Mini and nothing shows up on the scan. Home Assistant Broadlink integration works but the docker broadlink manager can't find the remote :(

ZoltrixGFC commented 2 years ago

I think @t0mer is on leave, not sure when he is due back.

t0mer commented 2 years ago

I think @t0mer is on leave, not sure when he is due back.

Hi @ZoltrixGFC I'm not on leave (: Working on other projects and also on a big update to the docker version of broadlink manager. Hopefully I'll get back to the Windows desktop version by mid-April.

t0mer commented 2 years ago

Same. RM4C Mini and nothing shows up on the scan. Home Assistant Broadlink integration works but the docker broadlink manager can't find the remote :(

Hi @pakshuang, What is the model of your RM Device?

pakshuang commented 2 years ago

Hey @t0mer, It says RM4C mini on the device, which is 0x62be in your docs.

LostOnTheLine commented 2 years ago

Windows version of Docker (if on WSL2 at least) does not allow net=host without going through a complicated process each time it's run to port forward to a changing on boot IP for the WSL2. That's why it sees nothing.

If there was a way to NOT do the net=host, even if it requires forwarding a bunch of ports, That'd be a big help. Does anyone know which ports it's using? As an application-level tool, that doesn't need to be running except when needed, I wouldn't mind forwarding a bunch of ports since it'll only be using them while I run the tool.

If there's perhaps a way to manually tell it what IP & MAC to look for?

I didn't see a windows version, just the Docker, I know everyone says it doesn't work but where can I find the Windows version?

ZoltrixGFC commented 2 years ago

@LostOnTheLine, @t0mer said he updated the Windows version mid-April, did you get the latest version?