search

tahsinhasem / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

GUI resize bug #2

Open tahsinhasem opened 7 months ago

tahsinhasem commented 7 months ago

When I make the gui full screen, the gui elements resize accordingly. However, when I press outside the GUI (or press the windows button), the gui elements resize themselves again. For example, if I make the app full size and then click on the task bar.

Note: this was done with the following long string of input inside the command bar - add [/ATTRIBUTENAME ATTRIBUTEVALUE]…ora [/ATTRIBUTENAMEATTRIBUTEVALUE]…

image.png

soc-pe-bot commented 7 months ago

Team's Response

We do not think it is a bug.

  1. With regards to functionality bugs, the user behaviour we are trying to tackle is the resizing of the GUI, and to do so we decided to make the GUI responsive to the resizing which works as intended, and the resizing MAY look like a bug, but we truly do not see how it affects the functionality of the app, neither does the resizing crop out inputs or any elements, nor does the resizing crash the app. More over this behaviour is stated in the UG as a tip.

Screenshot 2024-04-21 at 3.30.44 PM.png

Screenshot 2024-04-21 at 3.29.24 PM.png

  1. It is also not a feature flaw, since it is not necessarily a feature.

    Items for the Tester to Verify

    :question: Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

Reason for disagreement: Perhaps, the bug I am facing is a bit more niche that you interpreted it to be. The initial resizing feature works perfectly. It is only after the app has resized and I click outside the app GUI (or even press any button like the windows key) that the GUI element decides to resize itself again (definitely is distracting) although the width and height of the main GUI is same.

Although I agree that resizing does not affect the functionality of the app, but it does affect the quality of the app. There were no such GUI flaws in AB3. Perhaps you may flag it as a feature flaw. Regardless, it definitely is an unwanted behavior, fixing which will increase the quality and feel of the app.