search

tailscale / tailscale-qpkg

Package Tailscale client in QPKG
MIT License
459 stars 38 forks source link

Unable to open Tailscale with myQNAPcloud Mode #113

Open alextreeo opened 1 year ago

alextreeo commented 1 year ago

thank you for your development, but I have a problem during use.

In myQNAPcloud model Open Tailscale App: XML syntax error on line 22: element closed by

tailscale cannot open the configuration page to log in.

use version: 1.48.1

alextreeo commented 1 year ago

how to work using remote model access, only local network?

DentonGentry commented 1 year ago

The QNAP package works with QTS and QuTS Hero versions of the QNAP platform. It has not been tested with nor developed for myQNAPcloud.

alextreeo commented 1 year ago

myQNAPcloud is not an independent version, it is an official QTS version for secure remote access to NAS.

johntait commented 1 year ago

First, I'm not associated with Tailscale the company so my comment isn't official.

Tailscale provides secure remote access across the Internet just as myQNAPcloud does, but with a different feature set and implementation. They're alternatives to each other. If you use one you shouldn't need the other at the same time. As such there's no point in Tailscale's developers putting time and effort into making Tailscale work under myQNAPcloud.

alextreeo commented 1 year ago

First, I'm not associated with Tailscale the company so my comment isn't official.

Tailscale provides secure remote access across the Internet just as myQNAPcloud does, but with a different feature set and implementation. They're alternatives to each other. If you use one you shouldn't need the other at the same time. As such there's no point in Tailscale's developers putting time and effort into making Tailscale work under myQNAPcloud.

Thanks for your thoughts on this issue.

First of all, I agree with you that both Tailscale and myQNAPcloud provide secure remote access over the internet, but they are actually different.

myQNAPcloud can only be used for official APP or web access, but this also lacks the ability to access local services such as SMB, SHH, Docker, etc., which prevents me from accessing the service.

Tailscale can provide me with additional access to the above services. And can also be accessed by other smart devices on the network.

Essentially, I'm not saying these two services replace either one, but rather the other service helps me configure the other service to get up and running.

johntait commented 1 year ago

Clearly I misunderstood what you're trying to do.

Gabriele-LS commented 1 year ago

This happened to me when I tried to open the Tailscale app connecting to the NAS through myqnapcloud.com.