Raining Cats and Dogs Secret Lair Commander Deck

taw / magic-preconstructed-decks

Magic: the Gathering Preconstructed Decks

6 stars 9 forks source link

Raining Cats and Dogs Secret Lair Commander Deck #98

Closed davidmartos96 closed 4 months ago

davidmartos96 commented 5 months ago

Work in progress on the recent Cats and Dogs Commander precon from Secret Lair.

Things to note:

There are 3 alternative commanders
There are 2 bonus cards that I placed in Sideboard
The Planeswalker icon stamped cards are left to annotated the specific collector number. I don't know if you have a way to automate that, since there was an update for those PLST cards recently in other decks. DONE

davidmartos96 commented 5 months ago

cc @axxroytovu Did you use any particular script for the PLST versions in the Secret Lair decks? Or was your change in the PLST pull request manual?

axxroytovu commented 5 months ago

Manual unfortunately. I don't know what collector numbers scryfall is going to use for cats & dogs yet.

davidmartos96 commented 5 months ago

That's a bummer. I'll see if I can update the PR tomorrow.

I looked a few of the cards and they seem to be available on Scryfall for the correct set, so they might have added them recently.

They are listed in the "Non-foil reprints" section with the set code https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/secret-lair-commander-deck-raining-cats-and-dogs

taw commented 4 months ago

I missed that it was marked as no longer draft for weeks now.

taw commented 4 months ago

/Users/taw/github/magic-preconstructed-decks/data/cmd/sld/Raining Cats and Dogs.txt of type Commander Deck has unexpected section Sideboard

davidmartos96 commented 4 months ago

@taw Yes, those are the bonus cards that came with the precon. I'm not sure if you have a better section for them.

taw commented 4 months ago

@axxroytovu Is this the only product with random cards added like that (not tokens or display commanders)? Did we ever decide what we're going to do with them?

axxroytovu commented 4 months ago

I think we should treat them like the other secret lair bonus cards. E.g. // DISPLAY: Also includes one of: [SLD:683] Shadowborn Apostle, [SLD:650] Manaweft Sliver, or [SLD:654] Predatory Sliver. from the OMG KITTEH secret lair

axxroytovu commented 4 months ago

Oh wait are they random or you get both cards? If you get both cards then I think the Sideboard makes sense. If it's random, then we should follow the precedent with the other secret lair products

davidmartos96 commented 4 months ago

Oh wait are they random or you get both cards? If you get both cards then I think the Sideboard makes sense. If it's random, then we should follow the precedent with the other secret lair products

For this bundle they are not random, everyone got those 2 extra cards. Having an Extra/Bonus section could also be added, which is more general. Or use the sideboard

taw commented 4 months ago

I wanted to do bonus section, but IIRC every other non-randomized bonus card was a display commander or a token, so there were never any decks that needed it.

I guess it can be a Sideboard for now.