tawada / grass-grower

0 stars 0 forks source link

Add comprehensive unit tests for utility functions in utils/github_utils.py to ensure robustness and error handling. #107

Open tawada opened 2 weeks ago

tawada commented 2 weeks ago

After carefully reviewing the code, I found an issue that could be improved.

Issue: Lack of Unit Tests for Utility Functions

While looking over the provided codebase, it's apparent that the unit tests focus primarily on core functionalities related to generating and handling GitHub issues, as well as integrating with external services. However, the utility functions within utils modules such as github_utils.py, logging_utils.py, and retry_utils.py lack comprehensive unit tests.

Example:

In utils/github_utils.py, methods like exec_git_command, exists_repo, and make_owner_dir are critical since they interact heavily with the environment and the file system. Appropriate unit tests would ensure their robustness:

Potential Improvements:

  1. Mock File System Operations: Utilize fixtures to mock filesystem operations and commands to ensure that these functions behave as expected under various scenarios.
  2. Exception Handling: Make sure that all edge cases are being handled and tested, especially when dealing with subprocess command failures, non-existent paths, or other potential error cases.
  3. Code Coverage: Increase the overall code coverage by incrementally adding the tests for these utility functions, ensuring every critical action is tested.

Incorporating these unit tests would greatly enhance reliability and maintainability, making the system less prone to unexpected failures.

Example Test:

A simple unit test for utils/github_utils.py might look like this:

# test_utils_github_utils.py
import pytest
from utils.github_utils import exec_git_command_and_response_bool

def test_exec_git_command_and_response_bool(mocker):
    mocker.patch("utils.github_utils.subprocess.run", return_value=True)
    response = exec_git_command_and_response_bool('test_repo', ['git', 'status'])
    assert response == True

def test_exec_git_command_and_response_bool_fail(mocker):
    mocker.patch("utils.github_utils.subprocess.run", side_effect=subprocess.CalledProcessError(1, 'git'))
    with pytest.raises(Exception):
        exec_git_command_and_response_bool('test_repo', ['git', 'status'])

Implementing tests such as the one above will help in catching potential issues early and makes the development process more robust.