Spec Review

[jridgewell]

• [ ] Why do we need a "ASCII punctuators that need escaping" phrase?
  • Can't we just define the chars inline in (the only place that it's used) the CharSet construction? Eg, https://tc39.es/ecma262/#sec-compiletocharset's CharacterClassEscape :: d production
• [x] Nit: rename cuList to something else. Maybe escapedList?
• [x] > If c is the first code point in cpList and c is a DecimalDigit, then
  • I don't see the phrase "is the first … in" anywhere else. I think we can update that to state "if cuList is empty" and use a defined "is empty" phrase and keep the same behavior.
• [x] There are several references to cuList that need to become _cuList_
• [x] > Append the elements of the UTF16Encoding (10.1.1) of c to cuList
  • What is UTF16Encoding? That 10.1.1 is 10.1.1 [[GetPrototypeOf]] ( )
• [x] There are several 0x00XY references "unicode" references, shouldn't they all be U+00XY?
• [x] DecimalDigit and WhiteSpace should be |DecimalDigit| and |WhiteSpace|
• [x] > and c is a DecimalDigit
  • c is a code point, can you compare it to a DecimalDigit production?
• [x] u> and c is a WhiteSpace
  • c is a code point, can you compare it to a WhiteSpace production?
• [x] > c is a CharSetElement of toEscape
  • c is a code point needs to be cast to a CharSetElement before we can check if it's an element of the set.

[ljharb]

Why do we need a "ASCII punctuators that need escaping" phrase?

i suppose i could do it inline, but i'd still want a note to describe the list a bit, and the dfn seemed cleaner to me.

[ljharb]

@jridgewell please rereview; i've addressed all your comments.

[jridgewell]

Everything in my original list looks good. But a new thing I've noticed, we're appending both Code Units and Strings to escapedList:

- Append code unit U+005C (REVERSE SOLIDUS) to escapedList.
- …
- Append the elements of [UTF16EncodeCodePoint](https://tc39.es/ecma262/#sec-utf16encodecodepoint)(c) to escapedList.

[ljharb]

@jridgewell thanks, fixed! lmk if there's more items, or if i can check you off :-)

[jridgewell]

LGTM