Path to Stage 4

[caridy]

Stage 4

• [ ] committee approval
• [ ] implement in two browsers
  • [ ] WebKit (WIP) (temporarily removed)
  • [ ] Chromium, patch(behind a flag)
  • [ ] Firefox (behind a flag)
• [ ] HTML Integration WIP
• [ ] WebIDL Exposed=* annotation WIP
• [x] significant in-the-field experience
  • [x] Polyfill
  • [x] Near-membrane framework
• [x] merge test262 tests
• [x] write test262 tests

  Stage 3

• [x] committee approval
• [x] spec editor signoff
• [x] spec reviewer signoff
• [x] receive implementor feedback
• [x] flesh out naming research

  Stage 2

• [x] receive developer feedback
• [x] committee approval
• [x] spec text written
• [x] spec reviewers selected

  Stage 1

• [x] presentation by @dherman

[koba04]

This spec reached stage2. Have the todos in stage2 been done?

[caridy]

@koba04 yes, but we are still looking for formal reviewers, probably will select them in the next meeting in July.

[caridy]

Update: Yesterday, an update was presented to the committee (https://github.com/tc39/proposal-realms#presentations) with overall good feedback. Reviewers were selected, and with that, we are gearing toward attempting to get to stage 3 in the upcoming meetings.

[leobalter]

I added some updates with the current patch proposed for WebKit and the html integration bits.

[evisong]

• [ ] WebKit (WIP) (temporarily removed)

I'm sorry to interrupt, but do you happen to have any tickets, release notes or changelogs explaining why ShadowRealms are implemented by WebKit but then removed? Thanks.

[leobalter]

TC39 agreed to hold browser release until the HTML integration is finished. That work is going slower than expected due to financial/sponsor reasons. I'd love to continue this, but I'm still working on making the resources available.