Review 10: Settings Configuration

[silviadebenedictis]

Overview

The focus for this code review will be centered around the default data and routing of the pages.
Please pay attention too:

• Javascript issues
• React components

Review Branch

review-xxx

Files to review

• settings.development.json
• app.jsx

Checklists

• Architecture
• Design
• JS
• React
• Testing

Due date

Monday, April 8th 11:55pm

For more information

The review process is documented at: http://courses.ics.hawaii.edu/ics414s21/morea/review/reading-idpm-review.html

[mikhail-shkaralevich]

App.jsx

DE-03: L21-41; L96-100

settings.development.json

Looks good

[silviadebenedictis]

Settings.development.json

• L77-82 Remove 'defaultData'

App.jsx

• DE-03: UserProfile file imported multiple times

[zhuochenggan]

App.jsx

• Consider removing multiple unused import

Setting.development.json

• Removing defaaultData that belongs to the stuff collection

[gavyngostage]

Settings.development.json

• Looks good, but need to remove unused data

App.jsx

• Unused imports: 'UsersProfilesPage' and 'UserProfile'

[ThanhLy1]

Settings.devlopment.json

• Removed non use data

App.jsx

• Duplicate Routes: Remove duplicate route definition for /nonprofits to avoid routing conflicts.
• Console Logs: Eliminate console.log statements for production readiness and cleaner code.
• Custom Hooks: Consider creating custom hooks for authentication and role checks to simplify ProtectedRoute and AdminProtectedRoute components.
• PropTypes Usage: Ensure comprehensive coverage with PropTypes for all components to enforce type safety.
• Accessibility: Enhance navigation management, focusing on improving user accessibility.
• Error Handling: Implement detailed user feedback for unauthorized or unauthenticated access.
• Loading States: Maintain consistent loading state indications across all routes to improve user experience.
• Comment Consistency: Update comments to accurately reflect current logic and route configurations.

[joelvanta]

Settings.development.json

• Probably remove or edit unrelated defaultAccounts.
• Make at least 2 admin accounts to verify admin components to be working.

App.jsx

• There are 2 unused imports (UsersProfiles and UserProfile). Try renaming those pages or removing them.
• There are unexpected console statements in lines 103 and 121.