search

team-vigir / flexbe_behavior_engine

Contains the behavior engine FlexBE.
https://flexbe.github.io
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
130 stars 73 forks source link

Live-View of userdata #21

Open fmauch opened 7 years ago

fmauch commented 7 years ago

When reviewing the execution of a larger behaviour it is quite usefull to be able to see the current userdata and it's contents, so it is easier to debug what's currently going on.

While it is already possible to see a state's userdata and it's remapping, the userdata's content is not exposed to the user in the control view.

pschillinger commented 7 years ago

Yes, values of userdata are not being displayed. This would potentially require a significant amount of data transmission and userdata can contain arbitrary objects.

However, I agree that it would be very useful in some cases and especially for debugging before deploying a system. I can very well imagine to add something like an on-demand value display to the Runtime Control view of the UI.

Anyone, feel free to post ideas or requests regarding realization so that I can incorporate them.

fmauch commented 7 years ago

publishing the userdata to a topic whenever a transition happens would be an option. This can be created only if a subscriber to this topic exists, so the transfer overhead would be optional to the user.

Also, publishing (or showing) a list of userdata keys and then some on-demand display sounds like a good way to go.

dcconner commented 7 years ago

I support on demand only publishing of userdata to a topic, preferably time stamped for data logging.

The question would be how to organize for greatest utility, without incurring significant overhead.
Just logging user data as a char buffer would be simply, but not very useful with rqt_bag or other tools. What python tools could we use to allow us to extract and post process?

Adding structure (e.g. via python pickle) would incur overhead, but at least we could read from bag file and extract data, even if we could not view in rqt_bag.

dcconner commented 1 year ago

Should we add a state that will publish userdata on_enter then just return done ?

Possibly dump all by default, or only a specific key if specified?

dcconner commented 1 year ago

Note that Noetic now has a get_userdata service. We will soon push this to ros2-devel branch at the new home https://github.com/flexbe/flexbe_behavior_engine