search

techmatters / soil-id-algorithm

GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1 stars 0 forks source link

Soil ID is returning 100% in some locations #169

Open DerekCaelin opened 2 months ago

DerekCaelin commented 2 months ago

Pulling from Courtney's comment

On iOS, I created a site at 41.7063, -72.63145. In the temporary site I got 80% for Pootatuck. Upon becoming a permanent site, it becomes 100%.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Create a temporary pin at 41.7063, -72.63145
  2. Look at soils list
  3. Convert into a permanent site
  4. look st soils list
  5. See issue

Expected behavior

soils have location percentages other than 100%

Actual behavior

Some soils get 100% match

Additional context

DerekCaelin commented 2 months ago

At 44.04219, -107.7188 I don't have a 100% match of soils

44.16471, -107.33253

DerekCaelin commented 2 months ago

@CourtneyLee333 are there other locations where you're getting a 100% match?

CourtneyLee333 commented 2 months ago

@DerekCaelin on v1.0.2 (190) beta I no longer get 100% match on the original example coords or several other locations I tried.

DerekCaelin commented 2 months ago

OK! Closing this issue for now. I will continue to look out for instances of 100% matches

DerekCaelin commented 1 month ago

On iOS, I created a site at 41.7063, -72.63145. In the temporary site I got 80% for Pootatuck. Upon becoming a permanent site, it becomes 100%.

jjmaynard commented 1 week ago

@DerekCaelin This difference is due to the display of the location-score at a temporary site and the data-location-score once a site is created. This relates back to our discussion about the use of remotely sensed data to refine the data score without the user having to enter information. The reason it is reporting 100 is because it is being normalized. I have updated the code to remove the normalization step.