teddy-gustiaux / default-bookmark-folder

WebExtension allowing you to choose the default bookmark location folder and quickly bookmark pages via a dedicated icon.
https://goo.gl/WtfpPH
MIT License
136 stars 17 forks source link

Issues on Firefox 113 when selecting a directory during manual save with CTRL+D #543

Closed spacesynth closed 1 year ago

spacesynth commented 1 year ago

This is a Bug Report

Description

Manually selecting a directory fails storing the bookmark in the desired location.

Steps to reproduce the problem

  1. CTRL+D
  2. select another directory like "food links"
  3. the bookmark is saved to the main directory not the "food links" directory
  4. retrying with CTRL+D shows the "food links" directory (in the popout), but it will always be in the main directory (actual location)

Expected behavior

Save to the selected directory if I override the default one in the CTRL+D popout menu. This is clearly an issue caused by Mozilla updating Firefox, as the addon worked perfectly before.

Specifications

Screenshots

Should be easy enough to reproduce, but if really required I can record the issue.

Additional context

If you need logs I can provide them.

siffegh commented 1 year ago

I can reproduce the problem on v113.0/Win7.

vitalii2011 commented 1 year ago

I confirm. There was such an inconvenience in Firefox 113.

Dainslaif commented 1 year ago

This is still happening, but has changed slightly. It will still force-save to the default directory initially, but now when you Ctrl-D to review the bookmark, it shows the bookmark's actual location. Updating to the desired directory does move the bookmark.

jkcdarunday commented 1 year ago

Dainslaif's comment happens on Linux on Firefox v117.0a1. This has probably been messing up my bookmark folders for a while now 😢

spacesynth commented 1 year ago

user_pref("browser.bookmarks.defaultLocation", "menu________");

I'm abandoning this issue and will enforce the default bookmark folder via user.js permanently which enforces prefs.js on launch.