search

tedsalmon / BlueBus

A Bluetooth module for vehicles equipped with I-Bus
Other
169 stars 41 forks source link

Caller hears echo of their own voice #81

Closed christrunk closed 2 years ago

christrunk commented 3 years ago

Hi there,

Here's the spec of my car:

Car: E39 M5, 2003 (Dec 2002 build date) https://www.mdecoder.com/decode/cb37557

I'm using the factory fitted mic and speakers, but callers complain of hearing their own voice back as an echo on calls.

Is there anything I can do?

Many thanks, Chris

tedsalmon commented 3 years ago

Chris,

Please refer to this as the first step of troubleshooting: https://github.com/tedsalmon/BlueBus/wiki/Clear-Voice-Capture

Thanks! -Ted

christrunk commented 3 years ago

Hi Ted,

I knew you'd have the answer! :)

I've updated the CVC and got the message "Successfully Applied License", but callers say it's only "a bit better".

It's gone from "OMG I can't even speak to you it's so annoying" to "That's just distracting".

Is there something else we can do?

Many thanks, Chris

bcagnoni commented 3 years ago

Just thinking loud here: would mic gain setting have an impact on this? Default should be -23db according to the wiki page.

Sent from ProtonMail for iOS

On Tue, Aug 31, 2021 at 13:44, christrunk @.***> wrote:

Hi Ted,

I knew you'd have the answer! :)

I've updated the CVC and got the message "Successfully Applied License", but callers say it's only "a bit better".

It's gone from "OMG I can't even speak to you it's so annoying" to "That's just distracting".

Is there something else we can do?

Many thanks, Chris

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. Triage notifications on the go with GitHub Mobile for iOS or Android.

dertimaushh commented 3 years ago

What's the part number of your microphone? I think there's one (newer version) that doesn't work with Bluebus algorithm that cancels the echo. Changed mine last year - and no more caller complaints afterwards :-)

dertimaushh commented 3 years ago

Found this:

I highly recommend the OE microphones with these part numbers: 84318380338 and 84318380319.

AVOID: 84316938762. It implements a much higher gain pre-amplifier which sometimes interferes with the BlueBus's echo cancellation algorithm and allows the caller to hear themselves over your speakers.

I'm not too sure what the difference between 338 and 319 are, honestly

Thanks! -Ted

christrunk commented 3 years ago

Thanks for your kind help guys, but I think my settings and mic are looking okay?

🤔

PXL_20210901_192106937

PXL_20210901_192223386

dertimaushh commented 3 years ago

Yes that looks all good.

tedsalmon commented 3 years ago

@christrunk,

How loud is the in car volume on calls? At some point, the AEC is unable to distinguish echo from other parties in the vehicle depending on volume :/. Everything else looks great.

Thanks! -Ted

christrunk commented 3 years ago

How loud is the in car volume on calls? At some point, the AEC is unable to distinguish echo from other parties in the vehicle depending on volume :/. Everything else looks great.

The volume is normal I would say, not particularly loud but naturally loud enough to go over road noise at 70mph

tedsalmon commented 3 years ago

@christrunk

The volume is normal I would say, not particularly loud but naturally loud enough to go over road noise at 70mph

Hmm. Can you play around with the volume and see if that has any impact? What's the serial number of your unit? If you don't have Navigation to get that info, just tell me when your BlueBus was mailed out.

Thanks! -Ted

bmos commented 3 years ago

I just got my dad's 540i set up for bluetooth calls and noticed this same issue (although he has the not-recommended 84316938762). Bluebus serial was in the 500s and it shipped sometime last summer (August I think). His voice is also pretty quiet. Should I get him the older 84318380338 mic?

tedsalmon commented 3 years ago

I just got my dad's 540i set up for bluetooth calls and noticed this same issue (although he has the not-recommended 84316938762). Bluebus serial was in the 500s and it shipped sometime last summer (August I think). His voice is also pretty quiet. Should I get him the older 84318380338 mic?

I would go with 84318380319 off eBay. I've seen many have success with this microphone lately.

-Ted

shintopig commented 2 years ago

I've emailed @tedsalmon about this but I figured I'd add it here as well. Done the troubleshooting with no luck.

I bought 84318380338 and even with the most recent updates have that echoing problem. So maybe avoid this one? Unsure.

I'm going to purchase 84318380319 and update to see if that fixes things.

And I guess I'll avoid 84316938762.

(Just FYI I have a 99 E46 sedan)

christrunk commented 2 years ago

@shintopig

I never managed to resolve this one. I ran out of time and ended up buying some Airpods anyway!

I have all the updates and correct kit in the car, but lowering the volume did help.

tedsalmon commented 2 years ago

To close the loop on this, there are a few things to keep in mind:

If none of these things do it, then the only room for improvement lies in turning the volume down. Turn it down as much as you can while making sure you can still hear the caller. These steps haven't failed me yet, but it can be annoying to toy with the volume :(

-Ted

Keff789 commented 1 year ago

I have the same issue, is clear voice capture still needed/recommanded for HW2.0?

tedsalmon commented 1 year ago

I have the same issue, is clear voice capture still needed/recommanded for HW2.0?

No. What microphone are you using (Part Number) and what Mic gain are you at?

-Ted

Keff789 commented 1 year ago

Mic Gain is at the moment at 0 db and the microphone is a 8431-6938762. I have also a 8380319 lying around, that i could test. Regarding to your üpst from june 29 2022 would you recommend to switch to the 319 and set the mic gain to 23db? On my car it does not show negative db numbers, has that changed on HW2.0?