search

telegramdesktop / tdesktop

Telegram Desktop messaging app
https://desktop.telegram.org/
Other
26.21k stars 5.2k forks source link

Voice message replies auto opens a new reply #25341

Closed ILoveSkilledCoders closed 1 year ago

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

Steps to reproduce

After replying to a comment with voice message, TG controls my computer and starts the reply process to that message again.

I reply to someone using VM and after I send it, TG does a reply to, to the same message again so the text field is waiting for me to do a VM or type. This has been going on for days now since your first update & it's very frustrating.

Someone else said he's also having that problem.

Expected behaviour

I reply to a message with a VM & it no longer shows that I'm trying to reply to a message.

Actual behaviour

See above

Operating system

8.1

Version of Telegram Desktop

4.3.1

Installation source

Static binary from official website

Logs

No response

23rd commented 1 year ago

Unfortunately I can't reproduce, can you share a demonstration video?

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

Unfortunately I can't reproduce, can you share a demonstration video?

So when I tried to do a video for you guys a few days ago I couldn't get the bug to reproduce.

Then just now without the video I tried it, again, couldn't get it to reproduce, but then when I left a long message it happened again, then when I left over a minute message again, it happened, so I think when it's a 10 sec test VM it doesn't do that, but I'm pretty sure I've done tests before for that short & it happened or it's becoming intermittent or only with some accounts, but earlier this week it was happening with everyone.

And there's no way I'm going to record a video of me leaving a message for someone for 18 mins.

I'll see if I can try it with another account later on.

Thanks

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

Unfortunately I can't reproduce, can you share a demonstration video?

Ok, I finally managed to get a video, but can I PM it to you please. I don't want it public, it has people's comments in it.

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

@23rd could you check my post also? I have the same issue

23rd commented 1 year ago

@ILoveSkilledCoders You can privately send a video to t.me/preston.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

@ILoveSkilledCoders You can privately send a video to t.me/preston.

I messaged you, saw that you & I had talked once before, messaged to confirm you are tech support for TG & you ignored me, then I tried to message you again & got this. https://i.imgur.com/n1h6Zsr.png did you just mark me as a spammer for no reason?

john-preston commented 1 year ago

@ILoveSkilledCoders this is my account, I have no idea if I blocked you, sorry.

What is your username? Let me unblock several last blocked users 🙈

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

@ILoveSkilledCoders this is my account, I have no idea if I blocked you, sorry.

What is your username? Let me unblock several last blocked users see_no_evil

@ourfreesociety

But why does you blocking me put me in TG jail? That's not fair. :(

And all I did was ask you if you were from TG tech support & you could see we talked once before, why would you block me?

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

@ILoveSkilledCoders he's not tech support, he's tdesktop developer and he can't ban you globally

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

@ilya-fedin he's not tech support, he's tdesktop developer and he can't ban you globally

Well what I've come to learn is that if even one person does something to my profile, it puts me in TG jail.

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

@ilya-fedin as i said, i have identical problem. Just answer with voice message on received voice message, it should be easily replicated.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

So... I replaced my HD with an SSD HD & also went back to Win 7 from Win 8.1

The volume issues are fixed, BUT this issue still remains.

And b/c I isn't rush to turn off auto updates in settings, it updated to the latest version.

I wanted to see if the older version was doing it b/c it wasn't when I was on it.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

@ilya-fedin as i said, i have identical problem. Just answer with voice message on received voice message, it should be easily replicated.

I already figured out that it only happens after the 1 minute mark & I told them that above.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

So it doesn't seem like anyone is going to fix this HUGE bug.

I DID confirm that it only started happening after the update after this version - tsetup-x64.4.1.0 - or maybe one after that when I first complained.

I had to redo my Windows 3 times & I rushed to turn off auto updates on TG the very last time & I never had the problem, then I had to log into TG again & the update took place & again, back to this bug.

It happened on both Win 8.1 & Win 7.

PLEASE fix it.

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

So it doesn't seem like anyone is going to fix this HUGE bug.

I DID confirm that it only started happening after the update after this version - tsetup-x64.4.1.0 - or maybe one after that when I first complained.

I had to redo my Windows 3 times & I rushed to turn off auto updates on TG the very last time & I never had the problem, then I had to log into TG again & the update took place & again, back to this bug.

It happened on both Win 8.1 & Win 7.

PLEASE fix it.

Agreed. Its super annoying and still no reaction at all from Telegram team. @ilya-fedin any thoughts??

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

As far as I understand, neither @john-preston or @23rd can reproduce the issue and since @ILoveSkilledCoders got a spam block, his messages haven't reached @john-preston in Telegram, so the issue has stalled.

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

@ilya-fedin OK, can i raise a new standalone issue with gif animation? This is ultra annyoing, approx month with that issue, PC desktop client became unusable..

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

I don't see any reason to create a duplicate issue, this won't help at all

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

I guess there's not so much people affected (or there were way more participants in the issue), so the issue is treated as a minor one and developers are currently busy with really prioritized tasks (features for the next release).

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

I don't see any reason to create a duplicate issue, this won't help at all

As far as i understood -> duplicating of issue makes more sense, since telegram team fixes it with 1-2 day (as it was with archived chats and UI bug here-> #25413 ,#25408 and here )

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

Those don't look like duplicates or one of them would be closed as a duplicate

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

I guess there's not so much people affected (or there were way more participants in the issue), so the issue is treated as a minor one and developers are currently busy with really prioritized tasks (features for the next release).

That's the problem. I think it has a reference to Win 8.1... and what are we left to do?

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

Well, you can try to do what @ILoveSkilledCoders can't do due to the spam ban?

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

As far as I understand, neither @john-preston or @23rd can reproduce the issue and since @ILoveSkilledCoders got a spam block, his messages haven't reached @john-preston in Telegram, so the issue has stalled.

The problem is that @ILoveSkilledCoders didn't upload video example of it here, so he decided to send it directly to @john-preston and received spam block.

Well, you can try to do what @ILoveSkilledCoders can't do due to the spam ban?

I would like to raise a new issue and this one can be closed i guess?

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

No, your duplicate one will be closed. Why you so want to create a new one? Just post any relevant details here.

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

No, your duplicate one will be closed. Why you so want to create a new one? Just post any relevant details here.

because its already spammed with non-relevant details.

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

Well, you have the choice of posting here or silently waiting

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

Well, you have the choice of posting here or silently waiting

thats not polite...

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

You can use in-app support if you want polite response. This is a place to discuss issues with open source rules (you want it @ you fix/implement it or silently wait). It's not for end users expecting tech support level response.

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

You can use in-app support if you want polite response. This is a place to discuss issues with open source rules (you want it @ you fix/implement it or silently wait). It's not for end users expecting tech support level response.

  1. in-app support doesn't answer at all.
  2. we're actually already in process of discussion about the issue and you're telling me "you have the choice or silently wait", which sound not polite from a telegram team member(contractor?).
ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago
  1. Apparently there's no enough volunteers for your account's language.
  2. It's the truth, like you it or not. If you want to say something, say it here, you can't create a duplicate. This place is not official to Telegram, by the way. The only official places are the bugs & suggestions platform and in-app support.
23rd commented 1 year ago

As long as there is no any video demonstration, this ticket will be unresolved.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago
  1. Apparently there's no enough volunteers for your account's language.
  2. It's the truth, like you it or not. If you want to say something, say it here, you can't create a duplicate. This place is not official to Telegram, by the way. The only official places are the bugs & suggestions platform and in-app support.

I already posted it there & as usual, no response.

https://bugs.telegram.org/c/21810

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

As long as there is no any video demonstration, this ticket will be unresolved.

I have the demonstration. Can you give me your TG handle & I'll send it to you?

Thanks

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

As far as I understand, neither @john-preston or @23rd can reproduce the issue and since @ILoveSkilledCoders got a spam block, his messages haven't reached @john-preston in Telegram, so the issue has stalled.

The problem is that @ILoveSkilledCoders didn't upload video example of it here, so he decided to send it directly to @john-preston and received spam block.

Well, you can try to do what @ILoveSkilledCoders can't do due to the spam ban?

I would like to raise a new issue and this one can be closed i guess?

It wasn't just that I got blocked, it was that he didn't respond.

I had spoken to him once before & he ignored me then too.

I'm not going to send a private video to someone who doesn't even respond to PMs to confirm they actually work with/for TG.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

I guess there's not so much people affected (or there were way more participants in the issue), so the issue is treated as a minor one and developers are currently busy with really prioritized tasks (features for the next release).

That's the problem. I think it has a reference to Win 8.1... and what are we left to do?

No, like I said, it's also on Win 7.

AND now when I click on a video, often it goes to a black screen. :(

ilya-fedin commented 1 year ago

I already posted it there & as usual, no response.

Yeah, it's official, but as far as i heard understaffed.

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

No, like I said, it's also on Win 7.

yes, its kinda from Win 7 till Win 8.1 i guess. Can you share video here? Otherwise i can try to make gif animation... Problem is that i wouldn't like to share my personal chat\contact.. so i need to create somekind of fake one.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

No, like I said, it's also on Win 7.

yes, its kinda from Win 7 till Win 8.1 i guess. Can you share video here? Otherwise i can try to make gif animation... Problem is that i wouldn't like to share my personal chat\contact.. so i need to create somekind of fake one.

Like I said further up, I don't want to share the video here for the same reason you don't want to share it LOL b/c it shows my list of people on the left & what was said.

I'm more than happy to share it with a staffer of TG, but in private.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

And this should be tested in groups too to see if you leave a VM after 1 min, it also does the same thing. Let me test it on one of my groups that's dead.

Yes, it does the same thing.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

On another note @VetaLioSTV - how did you emoji one of the comments above? I don't see any way to emoji comments LOL

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

@23rd , @john-preston , @Aokromes , @ilya-fedin OK, please take a look at demo(i hope for now its much more clear how it looks like):

Demo

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/15155286/205611574-e43cc3c3-fdd4-4c2f-97dc-78fa9cda1a9e.mp4

My suggestion -> let me create a new standalone issue and close that one (?).

PS This the most one ultra annoying bug which is almost reproducible one month+ on desktop client. Please assist...

23rd commented 1 year ago

@VetaLioSTV You can download a nightly build to check if the problem was resolved.

https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop/actions/runs/3619897265

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

@23rd at current moment i'm on other environment, so i can't test it for now.

@ILoveSkilledCoders could you check at your Win7 and post here a reply?

kirsan31 commented 1 year ago

I can say that this bug some times happens on win11 and win10 too.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

@23rd at current moment i'm on other environment, so i can't test it for now.

@ILoveSkilledCoders could you check at your Win7 and post here a reply?

Test my current version or that link you gave us?

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

I can say that this bug some times happens on win11 and win10 too.

Are you making note that it should be happening after 1 min. of talking?

Although it looks like Veta it happens even under the 1 min. mark.

I'm glad to see more people reporting this HUGE bug.

Thanks

VetaLioSTV commented 1 year ago

@23rd , @ILoveSkilledCoders as for version 4.4.1 x64 seems to be its already fixed and i cant reproduce it. Many thanks for fast assist.

ILoveSkilledCoders commented 1 year ago

@23rd , @ILoveSkilledCoders as for version 4.4.1 x64 seems to be its already fixed and i cant reproduce it. Many thanks for fast assist.

@23rd - how do I get the update? Mine is still on the 4.3.3 version.

23rd commented 1 year ago

https://desktop.telegram.org