people I am calling from mac desktop can't see the video even though it's on

vanyamlb commented 1 year ago

Steps to reproduce

start a video call
other side can't see your video
try turning off and on the video, it will say "...camera is on, off", but we can't see the actual video, only profile picture or black screen

Expected behaviour

companions see each other videos correctly (it works well on telegram from appstore, mac version, telegram lite also doesn't work)

Actual behaviour

companions can't see the video started from mac desktop

Operating system

Ventura 13.4.1 (c)

Version of Telegram Desktop

4.8.7

Installation source

Static binary from official website

Crash ID

No response

Logs

No response

john-preston commented 1 year ago

I can't reproduce :( TDesktop 4.8.12 beta <-> Android from Store, one-on-one call started from Android, both can see video if enabled.

Can you check the latest beta version and share:

who is calling (what device is calling, what device is accepting)
if it's a call or a voice chat in a group

vanyamlb commented 1 year ago

@john-preston

I just tried to install the beta but still the same.

MacBook Air 2015 13 inch with TDesktop 4.8.12 beta is calling to Xiaomi 11T 9.7.6 in a call.

Friends with other devices (on windows, iphone and other androids) couldn't see me both in calls or group chats. I see them. And they see that I turn on/off the cam from the text notification and sometimes see the black rectangle where it's supposed to be a video from my Mac.

john-preston commented 1 year ago

@vanyamlb But you see your video in the app, just they don't?

vanyamlb commented 1 year ago

@john-preston yes.

vanyamlb commented 1 year ago

The issue is gone. Telegram Desktop 4.9.5

vanyamlb commented 1 year ago

I'm sorry. Sadly I was able to see the video from MacBook on a windows computer, but not from my Android

b-rhyme commented 11 months ago

So it hasn't been resolved still? I have the same problem with MacBook Pro Mid-15 on Intel processor. When I call in TG somebody - people can't see me. Does anybody have any ideas what it can be? My guess is that a "broken" TG Desktop application.

github-actions[bot] commented 9 months ago

This issue has been automatically closed because no developer succeeded to reproduce the issue with the given reproduction steps. With only the information that is currently in the issue, we don't have enough information to take action. Please reach out if you find what's missing to reproduce the issue so that we can investigate further.

Note that GitHub is a developer communication platform. If you're an ordinary user seeking for help, get to support crew via Settings -> Ask question in the application.

mariagodlevska commented 9 months ago

I also have this issue. MacBookPro early 2015, Monterey 12.6.7, the latest version on TG I have my camera turned on but my friend doesn't see me in a video chat, only the screen with my profile pic. It's the same for contacts and non-contacts. People see me in group chats though.

vanyamlb commented 9 months ago

@mariagodlevska my Macbook Air is also early 2015 and I too still have this issue

socialdistortio commented 9 months ago

Same issue here. MacBook Air mid 2012. All permissions for the app granted, I can see the video, but companions do not see me. Tried to have a call both with iPhone and Android devices. Tried Telegram standalone, Telegram from AppStore and Telegram Lite from the Appstore - all have the same issue.

Segrey74 commented 8 months ago

I also have this issue. MacBookAir late 2015, Monterey 12.6.7, the latest version on TG

john-preston commented 8 months ago

@Segrey74 Can you please provide the exact version, because you may be using a different application.

Segrey74 commented 8 months ago

@john-preston macOS Monterey 12.7.3, Telegram 10.7.259037 AppStore, Macbook Air 2015.

Aokromes commented 8 months ago

@john-preston macOS Monterey 12.7.3, Telegram 10.7.259037 AppStore, Macbook Air 2015.

you are using https://github.com/overtake/TelegramSwift

Segrey74 commented 8 months ago

I tried this version. The result is the same.

github-actions[bot] commented 8 months ago

This issue has been automatically closed because no developer succeeded to reproduce the issue with the given reproduction steps. With only the information that is currently in the issue, we don't have enough information to take action. Please reach out if you find what's missing to reproduce the issue so that we can investigate further.

Note that GitHub is a developer communication platform. If you're an ordinary user seeking for help, get to support crew via Settings -> Ask question in the application.

mariagodlevska commented 8 months ago

Why is it closed again. People with older Macs still have this problem. Having basically zero support on the app doesn't make it easier. The issue still stands, I have to use other tools to communicate.

ilya-fedin commented 8 months ago

@mariagodlevska the bot says why: no developer was able to reproduce the issue and no action could be done on it therefore. Find what is missing in steps to reproduce, update the information and if any developer will be able to reproduce the issue, it will be reopened.

ethaniel commented 8 months ago

I own 3 Macbook Pros 2015 (all on the latest version available - Monterey 12.7.3), all of them have this problem. When the developers say that they can't reproduce, I have doubts that they are testing on the same hardware.

This problem is visible on both internal and external (usb) cameras. Funny enough, Whatsapp has the same problem too. However, Google Meet (in the browser) works perfectly fine. So it should be related to how the internal MacOS mechanisms handle video encoding.

john-preston commented 8 months ago

I don't have this hardware, sorry. Did anyone successfully reproduced that in a VM maybe?

ml111233 commented 7 months ago

If it's of assistance to anyone - have been struggling with this since last year. MacBook Air 2013 CTO top spec Core i7, 8gb RAM, Intel HD 5000 igpu with 1.5gb VRAM. (This laptop can run Sonoma today faster than it ran supported versions.)

All of a sudden, can't be seen on video calls. After all this time I've traced it back to the last working version of Telegram (not desktop) 9.3.1. Video is restored using that version. Hopefully that will allow a timeframe to narrow down what was changed, but my money is on GPU or encoding the webcam stream. In the current verision, group call video did still work, but had terrible frame rate.

At least Telegram video calls are usable again using this version. I've raised bugs for this with Telegram as obviously this version is behind on security updates, etc. and needs resolution.

I have zero issues with any other app - Zoom, Teams, Skype, FaceTime, any of the Safari or Chrome based chats. All work fine. It's only Telegram and Telegram Desktop.

Can you look at what changed with 9.4 with video calling which was the version where it stopped? OpenGL changes? Anything like that?

maxnzv commented 7 months ago

The same issue at MacBook Air 2017. Telegram version: 10.10.1.261717 Stable

dmitry-semenov commented 6 months ago

I encountered the same issue with my MacBook Pro 2015. While installing previous versions one by one, I discovered that the last working release is 4.6.0, as 4.6.1 is already broken. https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop/compare/v4.6.0...v4.6.1

telegramdesktop / tdesktop