Open wangxm-forest opened 1 month ago
@wangxm-forest Thanks for your work on this! Here's a few thoughts after discussing with a couple people:
@lizzieinvancouver Hi Lizzie, how many pipette tips should we order from this purchase?
@wangxm-forest Since pipette tips are supplies I think we should not order them yet.
I never heard back from David Lipson -- I'll ping him once more and ask for a reply by next Tuesday, but then we should pick out a centrifuge on our own.
@wangxm-forest David did not have specific recommendation for a centrifuge. Here's what I got:
Sorry, Lizzie. I was going to visit my friend's lab where she has some little centrifuges and see what type they were, but it keeps slipping my mind when I'm on campus. I love the story of the kids that made a centrifuge from a saladspinner for red blood cell collection in remote areas.
For pipettes, I like Gilson, if they still make them. I have some Finnpipettes, too. I think they are generally fine.
@lizzieinvancouver I finally heard back from Thermo Fisher, and they have a package available that includes both a microcentrifuge and the pipettes we need. Here's an image of the package:
The centrifuge is a bit larger than the one from WeberScience (22.5 x 24.3 x 35.2 cm vs. 27 x 22 x 15 cm), but it has a higher capacity, holding up to 24 samples. I think this one should work well for our needs.
I think we can also consider this as our benchtop centrifuge, or would you prefer we look into a larger model, such as one with dual rows to accommodate tubes of different volumes?
@wangxm-forest Thanks! How much is it and does it meet the RPM we need (for the DNAeasy kit)? How much would a 48 sample benchtop model cost?
@lizzieinvancouver
The first item is a tabletop centrifuge. The second item is a Microliter rotor which is compatible with the first centrifuge and make it able to handle 48 2mL tubes at once. The third item is the package they were promoting, with the pipettes, microcentrifuge and pipette tips.
Please let me know what do you think.
@wangxm-forest Thanks! Can you give me some of the specs for the benchtop centrifuge? I have not been able to find it online. Can you also let me know what type of pipettes the kit includes? I worry they may use the kit as a way to sell pipettes that are not great, but am not sure.
Does anyone sell the Gilson that David mentioned pipettes in Canada?
@lizzieinvancouver The benchtop centrifuge is this one. It allows us to handle 48 microtubes when equipped with the Microliter rotor, while the microcentrifuge in the package will not be able to handle 48 samples at the same time.
Pipettes the kit includes are Finnpipette F2, I looked online and many people like these pipette saying that they are smooth and sturdy. If you prefer Gilson, we can directly order from their website The price will also be a little bit cheaper if we go with Gilson.
@lizzieinvancouver Hi Lizzie, have you decided which centrifuge and pipettes should we get?
@wangxm-forest Sorry for the delay. I thought about it and I think we should SKIP the bench top one if the smaller one will work for our DNA purposes. (We can also visit another lab at UBC and borrow their centrifuge if we really need it.) So can you please order the smaller one and some Gilson pipettes? I leave it to you to decide we should get the kit and have extra pipettes or order separately.
@lizzieinvancouver I ordered the PIPETMAN Starter Kits from Gilson, which include the 2-20 µL, 20-200 µL, and 100-1000 µL pipettes. I know you requested the 20 µL, 100 µL, and 1000 µL, but unfortunately, they don’t sell them as a kit. I called their customer service to ask if we could exchange the 200 µL pipette for a 100 µL one, but had a very poor experience...They just hung up on me. I’ve also sent them an email. I'll see how it goes.
If they can’t change the 200 µL pipette for us, I believe the three pipettes in that kit should still be suitable for the work according to the manual you sent me.
Regarding the centrifuge, I asked ThermoFisher to send us a new quote on the microcentrifuge only. I don't think it worth buying the kit if we get pipette from Gilson. Their tips may not be interchangeable.
I reached out to ThermoFisher to ask if their vortex would be compatible with the Qiagen Vortex Adapter, but they were not sure either. Given this, I recommend that, instead of purchasing the ThermoFisher vortex, we buy the Vortex-Genie 2 Vortex as recommended on the Qiagen Vortex Adapter website to make sure they will be compatible with each other.
@wangxm-forest That sounds good!
@lizzieinvancouver Hi Lizzie, I placed an order for the vortex adapter from Qiagen, which allows us to shake 24 tubes at the same time on a vortex.
However, I called Qiagen, and they told me that the item is currently not available until the end of this month and they couldn't invoice us until the item has been shipped.
Given that the deadline for submitting all invoices is at the end of this month, I'm concerned that we may not be able to process this purchase in time.
Would you still like to proceed with the order, even if we cannot put the cost to the equipment money? The total for this item is CA$383.16. Sorry for being last minute.
@lizzieinvancouver We want to buy equipment for soil DNA extraction. I asked around and these are what I found so far:
Vortex (plus vortex adapter - Qiagen cat. no. 13000-V1-24) ThermoFisher Pros:
Cons:
WestLab Pros:
Cons:
Centrifuge 16,000x g standard benchtop, as around… ThermoFisher Here's a list of all centrifuge ThermoFisher is selling, you can roll down to see the ones with Max. RCF of 17000 x g, and most of them can take 24 samples.
Fresco™ 17 Microcentrifuge Refregirated This model have the temperature range of: -9℃-40℃, since we are dealing with DNA, probably the ability to operate at low temperature is an important thing?
Microcentrifuge for travel: WeberScientific Pros:
Cons:
Pipettes (P20, P100, P1000)
Pipettes prices can vary a lot. ThermoFisher ones are around 800 CAD each and WestLab ones are about 300 CAD each.