wolfy-j
commented
3 months ago The current bypass approach is to clearly define workflow method attribute at descendant.
Closed root-aza closed 1 month ago
wolfy-j
commented
3 months ago The current bypass approach is to clearly define workflow method attribute at descendant.
What are you really trying to do?
We are trying to start a workflow with a class descendant
Describe the bug
Minimal Reproduction
Code
```php go($workflow); } /** * @param RootWorkflow $workflow */ abstract protected function go($workflow): Generator; } ``` ```php ok(); } } ``` ```php withNamespace(Workflow::getInfo()->namespace) ->withTaskQueue('bus.bank_application') ->withParentClosePolicy(ParentClosePolicy::POLICY_ABANDON) ); $workflow->start(Workflow::getInfo()->execution->getID()); yield Workflow::await(fn(): bool => $this->status); } #[SignalMethod] public function ok(): null { $this->status = true; return null; } } ```StackTrace
```json { "message": "The given stub class \"App\\LoanApplication\\Workflow\\AWorkflow\" does not contain a workflow method named \"start\"", "source": "PHP_SDK", "stackTrace": "#0 /var/www/api/src/LoanApplication/Workflow/RootWorkflow.php:41\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\ChildWorkflowProxy->__call(\"start\",array(1))\n#1 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Scope.php:363\n App\\LoanApplication\\Workflow\\RootWorkflow->start()\n#2 [internal function]\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Scope->call(Closure,Temporal\\DataConverter\\EncodedValues)\n#3 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Scope.php:452\n Generator->valid()\n#4 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Scope.php:186\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Scope->next()\n#5 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Process.php:183\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Scope->start(Closure,Temporal\\DataConverter\\EncodedValues)\n#6 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Router/StartWorkflow.php:91\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Process->start(Closure,Temporal\\DataConverter\\EncodedValues)\n#7 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Interceptor/Pipeline.php:95\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router\\StartWorkflow->Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router\\{closure}(Temporal\\Interceptor\\WorkflowInbound\\WorkflowInput)\n#8 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Router/StartWorkflow.php:104\n Temporal\\Internal\\Interceptor\\Pipeline->__invoke(Temporal\\Interceptor\\WorkflowInbound\\WorkflowInput)\n#9 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Router.php:82\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router\\StartWorkflow->handle(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4),React\\Promise\\Deferred)\n#10 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Worker/Worker.php:91\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router->dispatch(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#11 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/WorkerFactory.php:422\n Temporal\\Worker\\Worker->dispatch(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#12 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Server.php:63\n Temporal\\WorkerFactory->onRequest(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#13 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/WorkerFactory.php:399\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Server->dispatch(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#14 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/WorkerFactory.php:269\n Temporal\\WorkerFactory->dispatch(\"\\n\ufffd\\u0005\\b\\u0001\\u0012\\rStartWorkflow\\u001a\ufffd\\u0005{\\\"info\\\":{\\\"WorkflowExecution...\",array(4))\n#15 /var/www/api/vendor/vanta/temporal-bundle/src/Runtime/Runtime.php:32\n Temporal\\WorkerFactory->run()\n#16 /var/www/api/vendor/vanta/temporal-bundle/src/Runtime/TemporalRunner.php:25\n Vanta\\Integration\\Symfony\\Temporal\\Runtime\\Runtime->run()\n#17 /var/www/api/vendor/autoload_runtime.php:29\n Vanta\\Integration\\Symfony\\Temporal\\Runtime\\TemporalRunner->run()\n#18 /var/www/api/public/index.php:7\n require_once(\"\\/var\\/www\\/api\\/vendor\\/autoload_runtime.php\")", "encodedAttributes": null, "cause": null, "applicationFailureInfo": { "type": "BadMethodCallException", "nonRetryable": false, "details": null } } ```Events Workflow
```json { "events": [ { "eventId": "1", "eventTime": "2024-05-17T07:44:33.985056926Z", "eventType": "WorkflowExecutionStarted", "version": "0", "taskId": "1048714", "workerMayIgnore": false, "workflowExecutionStartedEventAttributes": { "workflowType": { "name": "RootWorkflow" }, "parentWorkflowNamespace": "", "parentWorkflowNamespaceId": "", "parentWorkflowExecution": null, "parentInitiatedEventId": "0", "taskQueue": { "name": "bus.bank_application", "kind": "Normal", "normalName": "" }, "input": null, "workflowExecutionTimeout": "0s", "workflowRunTimeout": "0s", "workflowTaskTimeout": "10s", "continuedExecutionRunId": "", "initiator": "Unspecified", "continuedFailure": null, "lastCompletionResult": null, "originalExecutionRunId": "a675ae9a-f0af-426b-b48e-83a530ff2bc5", "identity": "35@6e8cab123894", "firstExecutionRunId": "a675ae9a-f0af-426b-b48e-83a530ff2bc5", "retryPolicy": null, "attempt": 1, "workflowExecutionExpirationTime": null, "cronSchedule": "", "firstWorkflowTaskBackoff": "0s", "memo": null, "searchAttributes": null, "prevAutoResetPoints": null, "header": { "fields": {} }, "parentInitiatedEventVersion": "0", "workflowId": "346c4917-9559-4043-9cfd-49da7afcbdff", "sourceVersionStamp": null } }, { "eventId": "2", "eventTime": "2024-05-17T07:44:33.985092009Z", "eventType": "WorkflowTaskScheduled", "version": "0", "taskId": "1048715", "workerMayIgnore": false, "workflowTaskScheduledEventAttributes": { "taskQueue": { "name": "bus.bank_application", "kind": "Normal", "normalName": "" }, "startToCloseTimeout": "10s", "attempt": 1 } }, { "eventId": "3", "eventTime": "2024-05-17T07:44:33.991138217Z", "eventType": "WorkflowTaskStarted", "version": "0", "taskId": "1048720", "workerMayIgnore": false, "workflowTaskStartedEventAttributes": { "scheduledEventId": "2", "identity": "bus.bank_application:7eaf76d2-14b7-4138-b2ec-5b96cfa7e42d", "requestId": "21da69d4-e7fb-4efa-bac0-9f2f228f72ce", "suggestContinueAsNew": false, "historySizeBytes": "278" } }, { "eventId": "4", "eventTime": "2024-05-17T07:44:34.088138134Z", "eventType": "WorkflowTaskCompleted", "version": "0", "taskId": "1048724", "workerMayIgnore": false, "workflowTaskCompletedEventAttributes": { "scheduledEventId": "2", "startedEventId": "3", "identity": "bus.bank_application:7eaf76d2-14b7-4138-b2ec-5b96cfa7e42d", "binaryChecksum": "", "workerVersion": { "buildId": "3850375e06e98d90ebe249b19dfded53", "bundleId": "", "useVersioning": false }, "sdkMetadata": { "coreUsedFlags": [], "langUsedFlags": [ 3 ], "sdkName": "temporal-go", "sdkVersion": "1.26.0" }, "meteringMetadata": { "nonfirstLocalActivityExecutionAttempts": 0 } } }, { "eventId": "5", "eventTime": "2024-05-17T07:44:34.088162967Z", "eventType": "WorkflowExecutionFailed", "version": "0", "taskId": "1048725", "workerMayIgnore": false, "workflowExecutionFailedEventAttributes": { "failure": { "message": "The given stub class \"App\\LoanApplication\\Workflow\\AWorkflow\" does not contain a workflow method named \"start\"", "source": "PHP_SDK", "stackTrace": "#0 /var/www/api/src/LoanApplication/Workflow/RootWorkflow.php:41\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\ChildWorkflowProxy->__call(\"start\",array(1))\n#1 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Scope.php:363\n App\\LoanApplication\\Workflow\\RootWorkflow->start()\n#2 [internal function]\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Scope->call(Closure,Temporal\\DataConverter\\EncodedValues)\n#3 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Scope.php:452\n Generator->valid()\n#4 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Scope.php:186\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Scope->next()\n#5 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Workflow/Process/Process.php:183\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Scope->start(Closure,Temporal\\DataConverter\\EncodedValues)\n#6 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Router/StartWorkflow.php:91\n Temporal\\Internal\\Workflow\\Process\\Process->start(Closure,Temporal\\DataConverter\\EncodedValues)\n#7 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Interceptor/Pipeline.php:95\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router\\StartWorkflow->Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router\\{closure}(Temporal\\Interceptor\\WorkflowInbound\\WorkflowInput)\n#8 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Router/StartWorkflow.php:104\n Temporal\\Internal\\Interceptor\\Pipeline->__invoke(Temporal\\Interceptor\\WorkflowInbound\\WorkflowInput)\n#9 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Router.php:82\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router\\StartWorkflow->handle(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4),React\\Promise\\Deferred)\n#10 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Worker/Worker.php:91\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Router->dispatch(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#11 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/WorkerFactory.php:422\n Temporal\\Worker\\Worker->dispatch(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#12 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/Internal/Transport/Server.php:63\n Temporal\\WorkerFactory->onRequest(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#13 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/WorkerFactory.php:399\n Temporal\\Internal\\Transport\\Server->dispatch(Temporal\\Worker\\Transport\\Command\\ServerRequest,array(4))\n#14 /var/www/api/vendor/temporal/sdk/src/WorkerFactory.php:269\n Temporal\\WorkerFactory->dispatch(\"\\n\ufffd\\u0005\\b\\u0001\\u0012\\rStartWorkflow\\u001a\ufffd\\u0005{\\\"info\\\":{\\\"WorkflowExecution...\",array(4))\n#15 /var/www/api/vendor/vanta/temporal-bundle/src/Runtime/Runtime.php:32\n Temporal\\WorkerFactory->run()\n#16 /var/www/api/vendor/vanta/temporal-bundle/src/Runtime/TemporalRunner.php:25\n Vanta\\Integration\\Symfony\\Temporal\\Runtime\\Runtime->run()\n#17 /var/www/api/vendor/autoload_runtime.php:29\n Vanta\\Integration\\Symfony\\Temporal\\Runtime\\TemporalRunner->run()\n#18 /var/www/api/public/index.php:7\n require_once(\"\\/var\\/www\\/api\\/vendor\\/autoload_runtime.php\")", "encodedAttributes": null, "cause": null, "applicationFailureInfo": { "type": "BadMethodCallException", "nonRetryable": false, "details": null } }, "retryState": "RetryPolicyNotSet", "workflowTaskCompletedEventId": "4", "newExecutionRunId": "" } } ] } ```Environment/Versions
temporal/sdk v2.8.1 temporal server v1.22.4