logprob scores when decoding from file, with return_beams=True

[thompsonb]

I am trying to generate an nbest list with logprob scores. I can get both the top N beams and their scores by running t2t-decoder in interactive mode and specifying something like --decode_hparams="beam_size=4,alpha=.6,batch_size=64,return_beams=True"

When I decode from a file using the same decode_hparams, I am able to get multiple tab separated beams, but I cannot figure out how to output/access the scores. Does anyone know how to output scores when decoding from a file? Thanks!

[qcl6355]

Probably, I think you should hack the code in utils/decoding.py. The output scores are stored in result["scores"], you need to customize output style format.

[rsepassi]

Sure, what I've cooked up is a new decode_hp, write_beam_scores which will write out the scores to the file. It'll work with both decode_from_file and decode_from_dataset when you're writing out to a file. Let me know how it goes once it comes out in the next release.

[ndvbd]

@rsepassi There is some strange here, performance wise.

When I export the model using tensor2tensor.serving.export with --decode_hparams="return_beams=True", the prediction time is x5 slower than when I predict with a model that was exported without this hparam.

This is strange for me because even when return_beams=False, we still get the 4 scores and the top beam. The only difference with return_beams=True is that we get the top 4 beams instead of only the top one. But should it really take more time? After all, during the beam search decoding you are holding the 4 top beams anyhow, so you only need to output them, but there is no further calculation to be done, isn't it?