search

terminal42 / contao-autoregistration

Auto-login your Contao users after their registration or account activation.
MIT License
7 stars 7 forks source link

Options in registration modul missleading #15

Closed Ernestopheles closed 8 months ago

Ernestopheles commented 1 year ago

Contao 4.13.16; PHP 8.1

Heading is

Mitgliederkonto aktivieren

The options of ´Mitgliederkonto aktivieren``` in registration module are 

 Nicht aktivieren
 Konto aktivieren
 Aktivieren und sofort anmelden

with this label

Neue Mitglieder automatisch aktivieren und anmelden (ohne E-Mail-Bestätigung).

This is missleading, as this extension is about

The extension allows to automatically login a Contao user after registration or when the account is activated.

So in case the system is configured to use double-opt-in and the user clicks the registration link, it's not about activating the member-account (so heading is wrong for this case). Also options 1 and 2 are senseless then. Only option 3 is partly meaningful, and this is what I wouls expect to have: To be able to choose if after registration the user will be automatically logged in or not.

I did not use the modus without double-opt-in. I assume then these options will be meaningful.

My suggestion: Separate the account-activation options from the automatically login options. Like so:

Mitgliederkonto für neue Mitglieder ohne E-Mail Bestätigung automatisch aktivieren? - checkbox

Neue Mitglieder sofort nach Registrierung einmalig automatisch anmelden (ohne Login-Formular)? - checkbox
aschempp commented 8 months ago

I agree this can be confusing (I was confused myself today), but I don't think we can change that without breaking stuff. I'll therefore leave this up to better documentation.