BLE: Failed to execute command: car could not execute command: SetChargingAmps failed

erikgieseler commented 1 month ago

Since some recent update, the charging-set-amps function no longer works via BLE.

Car: Tesla Model 3 LR 2021 Firmware: 2024.26.3.1

This command was executed: tesla-control -debug -key-file /home/admin/Tesla/private_key.pem -ble -vin LRW* charging-set-amps 6

Debug Log:

2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Set session cache file to ''
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Set OAuth token name to ''
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Set OAuth token file to ''
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Set keyring type to ''
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Set keyring Debug Logging to 'false'
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Client public key: 042a*
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Connecting over BLE...
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Creating new BLE device
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Searching for BLE beacon S*...
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] Connecting to BLE beacon a4*...
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [info ] Connected to vehicle BLE
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [info ] Connecting to car...
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [info ] Starting dispatcher service...
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [info ] Securing connection...
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [info ] Requesting session info from DOMAIN_INFOTAINMENT
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [info ] Requesting session info from DOMAIN_VEHICLE_SECURITY
2024-08-07T16:56:52+02:00 [debug] TX: 320208023a1212100380c1e0ef246bfc4cb1ce15332ce9079a0310c9564158ca7c49af01d846de0a2f717f72430a41042a5e6dde18e9d23e82b98d7b2fb758b69c60f9b1d62db6c94aac564652aa882c1cd65a3ce505c0b80c858b5520268c88c53154581598b830f8eeb71293bb3097
2024-08-07T16:56:53+02:00 [debug] TX: 320208033a121210e5afe06dbf56e8612a7401c0ab410bd99a03104f65b5182a792f88e741f2bf17e1a96772430a41042a5e6dde18e9d23e82b98d7b2fb758b69c60f9b1d62db6c94aac564652aa882c1cd65a3ce505c0b80c858b5520268c88c53154581598b830f8eeb71293bb3097
2024-08-07T16:56:53+02:00 [debug] RX: 321212100380c1e0ef246bfc4cb1ce15332ce9073a0208027a5e0805124104ba9141ad8beddf96d3a1b26cb29109396cc91b713d75755a2d0bc68d9255616dab616c79e0d0bba48cf36288587b4681a10cb9e53934fde4ae0702d6a04cd0fd1a10418d554227b16e3012912981951d1946256775000030056a2432220a20dd3f0a680c18a7df205972e38bc0692e96142ba49900657b68c1c5eb62ed9fcc920310c9564158ca7c49af01d846de0a2f717f
2024-08-07T16:56:53+02:00 [info ] [c9564158ca7c49af01d846de0a2f717f] Updated session info for DOMAIN_VEHICLE_SECURITY
2024-08-07T16:56:53+02:00 [debug] RX: 320208003a020802521f1a1d12160a14f8ed37c298b23b265cf5e214dc8e88093ac2a0421802220101
2024-08-07T16:56:53+02:00 [debug] [00] Dropping message to DOMAIN_BROADCAST
2024-08-07T16:56:54+02:00 [debug] RX: 32121210e5afe06dbf56e8612a7401c0ab410bd93a0208037a5e08251241042086b185dba7bd603cd8194105877148d87eef10da0dfcfa39f24ecf19c058a48edc6ab455c9ef6f594b36531bd177ac14f06446452a6fad3c6bc5369696b01a1a10df663b3fc0d5072c4078cc21d1e38dcc251feb070030056a2432220a2036e6171d272f43a0d821efbc4f1eb568024eb226875fb052ae3c86f0f62e70f79203104f65b5182a792f88e741f2bf17e1a967
2024-08-07T16:56:54+02:00 [info ] [4f65b5182a792f88e741f2bf17e1a967] Updated session info for DOMAIN_INFOTAINMENT
2024-08-07T16:56:54+02:00 [debug] TX: 320208033a121210e5afe06dbf56e8612a7401c0ab410bd99a0310fd9bb2753c04e6072d89271fe781c4645207c9efc78f965c396a80010a430a41042a5e6dde18e9d23e82b98d7b2fb758b69c60f9b1d62db6c94aac564652aa882c1cd65a3ce505c0b80c858b5520268c88c53154581598b830f8eeb71293bb30972a390a10df663b3fc0d5072c4078cc21d1e38dcc120cdab13cdfb00f82a50f0d988c18262524eb07002a10249d71252e2c32205ff4b00240b1f03e
2024-08-07T16:56:54+02:00 [debug] RX: 320208003a020802521f1a1d12160a14f8ed37c298b23b265cf5e214dc8e88093ac2a0421802220101
2024-08-07T16:56:54+02:00 [debug] [00] Dropping message to DOMAIN_BROADCAST
2024-08-07T16:56:55+02:00 [debug] RX: 32121210e5afe06dbf56e8612a7401c0ab410bd93a020803521e0a1c080112180a165365744368617267696e67416d7073206661696c6564920310fd9bb2753c04e6072d89271fe781c4649a0310347f75700b2bc752018d4ae71da7d348
Failed to execute command: car could not execute command: SetChargingAmps failed

sethterashima commented 1 month ago

Can you confirm that:

this is reproducible over BLE, but not over the Internet?
the error persists if you try again in 20 seconds?

The error indicates the infotainment system successfully received and authenticated the command, but could not execute the command. This can happen under normal circumstances if the infotainment system is in the process of booting/waking up and the service responsible for executing the command has not come up yet. But if you can reliably reproduce the error after giving the car time some time to finish waking up, then further investigation might be required.

erikgieseler commented 1 month ago

Yes, the error persists even after a waiting time of 20 seconds. I can only test the BLE commands as I don't use the Internet commands because the rate limits are far too low. However, it makes no difference whether the car is asleep or not. The error also occurs when the car is not asleep.

maart84 commented 1 month ago

I'm having the same error via the web calls. The weird thing is: I can't even change it in the tesla app itself anymore now. As soon as I try to set another Amperage I get a message: commad failed. Only changing it in the car still works and reflects back in the app. Maybe a Tesla bug? Car: 2019 SR+ with 2024.26.6

zlymeda commented 1 month ago

I have the same problem that started when I upgraded from 2024.20.9 to 2024.26.3.1. When updated to 2024.26.6, restarting my Tesla once did the trick. I was able to change the amps.

But today, I got updated to 2024.26.7 and can no longer change the amps. I tried restarting the car multiple times, but it did not work.

I tried:

official Tesla Android app
- fails via BLE
- fails via the internet
fleet API SDK
- fails via BLE

Also, I noticed that these commands work:

lock/unlock car
turn on/off the climate
sentry on/off
start/stop charging
lock/unlock charge port

These don't work:

change amps
open/close windows

I own the Tesla Model 3 LR 2019, if that helps.

erikgieseler commented 1 month ago

I can also no longer adjust the charging current via the Tesla APP.

zlymeda commented 1 month ago

interesting.

I went for a drive
restarted the Tesla away from home
tried the app right there on the parking lot - still getting the error
came home, plugged it in
tried to change the amps.. and now it works

doomastor commented 1 month ago

Hi, I have also the same problem. As zlymeda, I notice that isssues appeared after upgrading to 2024.26.3.

My Car is a SR+ 2021.

pkuehnel commented 1 month ago

Same issue here. Even with the official Tesla App, I cannot change the current anymore. BLE and Fleet API also not working. Changing the current in the car's infotainment screen is working. Issue in my third party app is here

Updated my 2019 Model 3 from 2024.20.9 to 2024.26.7. Since then, no current change possible anymore.

Edit: It looks like by far not all cars are affected but I have no idea which car/ carconfigs are affected and which are not.

coreGreenberet commented 4 weeks ago

Same issue over fleet api & tesla app. Tesla Model Y LR 2021: 2024.26.7

maart84 commented 4 weeks ago

Today I installed 2024.26.7 and it started working again. And in the official app too. model 3 2019 rwd.

pkuehnel commented 3 weeks ago

Looks like I found a solution. What you need to do: Disconnect the car charger, sit in the car, switch off the Bluetooth of your phone. Make sure that no BLE enabled phone, Key Fob,... is around. Note: BLE has a connection radius of > 20 meters, so best would be to disable Bluetooth of all phones and remove the battery from the key fob. Then restart the car by pressing both scroll wheels, wait for the car to reboot (I waited an additional minute after the navigation screen came back), enable Bluetooth on your device. Now it should work again.

coreGreenberet commented 1 week ago

Looks like I found a solution. What you need to do: Disconnect the car charger, sit in the car, switch off the Bluetooth of your phone. Make sure that no BLE enabled phone, Key Fob,... is around. Note: BLE has a connection radius of > 20 meters, so best would be to disable Bluetooth of all phones and remove the battery from the key fob. Then restart the car by pressing both scroll wheels, wait for the car to reboot (I waited an additional minute after the navigation screen came back), enable Bluetooth on your device. Now it should work again.

I didn't believe your solution as I did a normal restart, but removing the fob battery and turning off the BT from my phone did really the trick with the reboot

pkuehnel commented 1 week ago

Yep, no BLE device beeing around is important. I tried multiple reboots, Software Reinstall,... nothing helped, only a reboot without any BLE device helps. I know of about 15 cars where that helped and not a single one where it did not help.

zhy2020 commented 2 days ago

Hello, can I control the air conditioner through ble? I look at the code as if it is calling the Internet method

teslamotors / vehicle-command

BLE: Failed to execute command: car could not execute command: SetChargingAmps failed #287