search

testing-library / angular-testing-library

🐙 Simple and complete Angular testing utilities that encourage good testing practices
https://testing-library.com/angular
MIT License
717 stars 90 forks source link

Interop with RouterTestingHarness #383

Open lacolaco opened 1 year ago

lacolaco commented 1 year ago

Angular introduced RouterTestingHarness as a utility for testing a component that depends on the router.

RouterTestingHarness manages a root component to instantiate <router-outlet> and returns routed component by navigateByUrl(url, component) method. AFAIK, there is a conflict with the testing-library's render() approach. The responsibility for instantiating a ComponentFixture must be one or the other.

So, I can't suggest a specific solution yet, but I think that testing involving Router can be complex and this is precisely the kind of area that the Testing Library should help with. It would be desirable to provide a means to escape from MockRouter and MockActivatedRoute while still being able to use them with the Testing Library.

lacolaco commented 1 year ago

If we just want to query the generated DOM with the Testing Library, the within() function will solve this problem. Rather, I think it is more important to be able to take advantage of RouterTestingHarness while retaining the hiding and intuitive configuration of TestBed that render() achieves.

timdeschryver commented 1 year ago

Hi @lacolaco sorry, I missed this issue. While reading the introduction I was also thinking about this. But, I'm still not sure how to proceed with it 😅

Do you have any ideas? Or to ask the question differently, what use cases does it solve better than it does currently?

lacolaco commented 1 year ago

@timdeschryver I don't have yet.

After I wrote this issue, Angular v16 supports router input binding withComponentInputs(), which allows us to pass data as inputs instead of Router params. Use-cases about component reactivity with router params I imagined are almost resolved by the feature.

unknownbanana commented 4 weeks ago

I have a use-case for this (or at least for supporting routing). Navigation is a user-action and the primary goal of the Testing-Library framework is that it:

helps you test UI components in a user-centric way.

However, the testing-library offers no utility functions for navigation nor does the Angular Testing Library. The issue I'm facing is that I want to test a Component that has a \ and no other elements. I.e. all I can do is navigate to a certain route, and load a component. As far as I am aware the Testing Library does not support this kind of component with any type of utility function.