textbrowser / biblioteq

Archive and catalog the world for today's and tomorrow's generations! Awesome and everyware.
https://textbrowser.github.io/biblioteq/
Other
217 stars 46 forks source link

BQ and sound interaction with the user. #258

Closed meteos77 closed 1 year ago

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

today I tested the BA/Discover feature : it works very well

I have a suggestion for improvement : Can BQ make a sound when it can't find the document. This would avoid having to look at the screen to see if BQ has the document in its database.

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

You'd like a ting on success and a bong on failure. Or something. I could introduce blue or green text if that helps. Media sound files are nice but require audio cards.

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

last week I inventoried 250 books 237 were present so the interface answered "book". but I had to look at the screen 250 times to see if the field answered book.

A sound for a failure would have allowed me to concentrate on the documents and the computer beeps for a long time? just on the error not on the successes because it will become tiresome for the ears :-)

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

I don't want a symphonic sound but just the sound of the beep command before the sound cards

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

There's nothing standard about a beep.

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

So again, from previous discussions, proprietary software bundled with hardware includes audios because they're manufactured with such features. They're not features requested and added 20 years after the software is developed.

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

A beep may indicate a problem. So nothing standard about that too. I'd perform the scanning and then visually inspect the results. It's like a spell checker. You have to spell check. Audio will not help.

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

Yeah, you're requesting a feature that is not standard, is ambiguous, may be annoying if it's not optional (so that's another hit against this request because it requires yet another option), cannot be guaranteed to work, can cause a system to fail, etc.).

https://www.dell.com/community/Laptops-General-Read-Only/Beep-then-crash/td-p/1390807

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

I would prefer professional sounds instead. That's nicer, cleaner, intuitive, portable.

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

you need two "special BQ" sounds

if BQ does not know the scanned document, it emits the sound "not found if BQ knows the scanned document, it emits the "find in database" sound

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

There are open-source media sounds which are kind of standard.

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

I'm offering an improvement and you're arguing against it. OK!

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

I did not understand anything then; I am for the improvement

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

you know that I am for all improvements :-)

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

You have an Android? Smoke has a generic pleasant sound when a participant receives a message. So, something like that. [Standard] failure and [standard] success audio files. I also added something like this in Spot-On.

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

no recent android 4.2 or 4.4

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

I prefer laptops and then tablets. Tablets before small devices. Then there are portable Pis. Keyboards, monitors.

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

branches_trunk_Sounds_send.wav and branches_trunk_Sounds_receive.wav are cool

the other 2 more aggressive

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

tablets are good for people without computers

e.g.: my mother can look at her photos, play games (card, puzzle ...)

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

smartphone : having a computer in the pocket is cool, we have dreamed of it in our youth

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

Completed for Qt 5. I decided not to add an option for enabling the feature. A pleasant chime is played if an item is discovered in both sections of the Batch Activities Browser. Functional if a system supports Qt's Multimedia module.

Qt 6 remains to be reviewed.

textbrowser commented 1 year ago

OK, adding an option now. :) A sound file is played if an item is discovered.

meteos77 commented 1 year ago

as usual great

can we have a different sound in case of non discovery (red)