——
The CPR timelines of the profile looks like this:
This is consistent with the result obtained using the router filter to build the sport CPR timeline:
However, when you filter out the different tick types, it becomes apparent that top rope ticks are not shown consistently:
Top rope onsights are shown with green similarly to their respective lead ticks.
Top rope flashes are shown with red similarly to lead red point ascends
Top rope clean ticks are shown as grey, similarly to failed attempts.
Here are some photos to document it:
Onsight and flash top rope filter CPR timeline:
Here’s an example of how the routes are logged:
Clean top rope filter CPR timeline:
Hang dog and Attempt filter CPR timeline:
Similarly, top rope ascends show up in your trad timeline as failed climbs. Here are the ascends included in the profile’s Trad CPR timeline:
Here’s an example of how the routes are logged:
To me it looks like that the CPR timelines are based on the route gear style and not the climbed gear style. This may not be a bug, but it has the effect that some top rope climbs will become part of your trad timeline, which I would say is not representative, since it would be more similar to sport climbing. No matter what, I assume that a more detailed filter is needed when creating the timelines?
The routes might also have been logged wrong which is what creates the problem. In that case it is not super clear how to log routes in a manner that creates a consistent CPR timeline.
Lastly, I want to mention that the ascend pyramid for sport does not include top rope ascends at all:
This means there is an inconsistency between the Sport CPR timeline and the ascend pyramid. This may be by design, but it seems a bit confusing. I suspect the ascend pyramid is made using climbed gear style and not route gear style, which is what creates the inconsistency?
I hope this helps shed some light on the Top rope CPR timeline issues that has been raised.
Hey, I have noticed that there is an inconsistency about how top rope climbs are shown on the Sport CPR timeline and the Trad CPR timeline.
I can see that there are also other posts that raise problems with top rope ticks but I think they may be related to this issue, e.g.: https://github.com/theCrag/website/issues/4158)
In this example I’m using the ascends of the following profile: https://www.thecrag.com/climber/macela00
—— The CPR timelines of the profile looks like this:
This is consistent with the result obtained using the router filter to build the sport CPR timeline:
However, when you filter out the different tick types, it becomes apparent that top rope ticks are not shown consistently:
Here are some photos to document it: Onsight and flash top rope filter CPR timeline:
Here’s an example of how the routes are logged:
Clean top rope filter CPR timeline:
Hang dog and Attempt filter CPR timeline:
Similarly, top rope ascends show up in your trad timeline as failed climbs. Here are the ascends included in the profile’s Trad CPR timeline:
Here’s an example of how the routes are logged:
To me it looks like that the CPR timelines are based on the route gear style and not the climbed gear style. This may not be a bug, but it has the effect that some top rope climbs will become part of your trad timeline, which I would say is not representative, since it would be more similar to sport climbing. No matter what, I assume that a more detailed filter is needed when creating the timelines?
The routes might also have been logged wrong which is what creates the problem. In that case it is not super clear how to log routes in a manner that creates a consistent CPR timeline.
Lastly, I want to mention that the ascend pyramid for sport does not include top rope ascends at all:
This means there is an inconsistency between the Sport CPR timeline and the ascend pyramid. This may be by design, but it seems a bit confusing. I suspect the ascend pyramid is made using climbed gear style and not route gear style, which is what creates the inconsistency?
I hope this helps shed some light on the Top rope CPR timeline issues that has been raised.