search

theDavidCoen / LightningExchanges

List of exchanges that support Lightning Network
205 stars 52 forks source link

Bitstamp doesn't support using lightning for its exchange #15

Open fresheneesz opened 3 years ago

fresheneesz commented 3 years ago

Bitstamp "supports" lightning by running a lightning node and presumably forwarding transactions. However, since the exchagne doesn't support using lightning, I'd say its misleading to say they "support" it in the table. Perhaps there should be separate columns for deposit/withdrawal support vs some other kind of support.

theDavidCoen commented 3 years ago

Signalling support is specified as an icon in the column and in the legend (example: the exchange has LN nodes, will fully support LN but at the moment doesn't support deposits/withdrawals)

fresheneesz commented 3 years ago

Isn't the "Lightning support?" column redundant with the "status" column? I think it would make a lot of sense to combine them. As it stands, the "Lightning support?" column is misleading.

theDavidCoen commented 3 years ago

I see the "Lightning Support" as a declaration, while the "Status" as the current status of their Lightning implementation. So, for example, if an exchange support Lightning and has deposit/withdraw but put them in pause, we can change the status.

fresheneesz commented 3 years ago

Even if "Lightning support" is a declaration of support vs having actual service, its still ambiguous between the declaration of "Our exchange will support withdrawing and depositing via the lightning network" vs "Our exchange company will run a routing lightning node, but we have no plans to making withdrawing and depositing possible on the exchange via lightning". As it stands, given the nature of the list, readers would assume the former and not the latter.

theDavidCoen commented 3 years ago

I understand your point, but for the moment I will keep the two columns unless there is another solution that could clarify the difference between two exchanges that support LN but that are different in the way they do that.

fresheneesz commented 3 years ago

I suppose I would suggest perhaps the following changes:

  1. Change "Node URI" to "Runs LN Node" and use the existing icons to show status of that and put "URI: ..." if the node is up.
  2. Change the name of the "Status" column to "LN Deposit/Withdrawal" and continue using the appropriate icons but just for the case of deposit/withdrawal support.
  3. Add an icon for "declared" so you can then remove the "Lightning support?" column

That way both pieces of information are clearly distinguished. At the moment, I don't think there's any information in this chart about deposit-withdrawal support, right? Certainly would be nice to add - its why I got to this page ; )