thecodingdoc / neep

A tool to perform high-throughput survival analysis on splice variants
MIT License
2 stars 0 forks source link

JOSS Pre-edits and Suggestions #4

Closed rhagenson closed 4 years ago

rhagenson commented 4 years ago

All the edits I see necessary prior to JOSS acceptance:

Suggested changes:

* Examples are for showing the user what to expect, tests are for preventing feature regression so I do not see the two as equal, however there is no definite functional the two cannot be linked in some manner as long as the examples never break and the tests are able to break should a regression occur.

rhagenson commented 4 years ago

Authorship fixed on https://github.com/thecodingdoc/neep/commit/e6746bee4c17b95aeb6d099c0daf36fe56deee5a

rhagenson commented 4 years ago

License renamed to make it easier to find on https://github.com/thecodingdoc/neep/commit/c082b7773bf7d309191a844e346442f936933adb

scwest commented 4 years ago

Considering the complexity of the algorithm and the expected unit outputs, I don't think automated unit testing is optimal here. Under the JOSS review criteria, it is acceptable to have a list of commands for testing the code. We had added this to the README.

rhagenson commented 4 years ago

@scwest, that is your decision to make.

rhagenson commented 4 years ago

References fixed on https://github.com/thecodingdoc/neep/commit/98621b7ba679d298b7c725ac26883333a444c0a9

scwest commented 4 years ago

I have tagged the items that I'll complete in the original comment. Thank you Ryan for your helpful review and suggestions!

rhagenson commented 4 years ago

@scwest, sounds good. Glad to help!