search

theforumhelpers / theforumhelpers.github.io

The site for the Scratch group "The Forum Helpers"
https://theforumhelpers.github.io/
MIT License
26 stars 16 forks source link

Feature Request: forum helpers leaderboards #121

Open FunctionalMetatable opened 3 years ago

FunctionalMetatable commented 3 years ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? no, its a shefwerld-based forum helpers leaderboard

Describe alternatives you've considered n/a this is my best api yet

Additional context this - the current one i made, with the base from shefwerld

please can i be assigned

Accio1 commented 3 years ago

This seems like it should be an extension of shefwerld, not this site. @leahcimto thoughts?

FunctionalMetatable commented 3 years ago

This seems like it should be an extension of shefwerld, not this site.

This could be easily implemented with the tfh site, but for some reason I didnt bother making a leaderboard based on the tfh website, if you guys want I can?

leahcimto commented 3 years ago

@Accio1 @FunctionalMetatable I would say it could maybe be implemented in the future but right now it doesn't have much difference than shefwerld other than it only contains forum helpers. Maybe if you change some things up and make it match more with the current website here it could be implemented, or you could try to get it implemented in shefwerld itself.

Steve0Greatness commented 3 years ago

I made meh mockups: Screenshot 2021-06-06 6 11 08 PM Screenshot 2021-06-06 6 16 29 PM

They're not that great... but they took forever(mostly the nav bar, it looks so simple... but it's not...)

Shluffy commented 3 years ago

i think dark mode might be better to use the blue like https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/75220768/120946904-e7e71b00-c6f2-11eb-8a11-401a46647776.png - although the blue isn't 'dark'

Steve0Greatness commented 3 years ago

i think dark mode might be better to use the blue like https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/75220768/120946904-e7e71b00-c6f2-11eb-8a11-401a46647776.png - although the blue isn't 'dark'

That image came from a bug where a part of the page on the main site didn't turn to dark mode. I thought that I was a feature, but it wasn't, so I fixed the image.

Accio1 commented 3 years ago

@FunctionalMetatable is this still something you are interested in implementing?

webdev03 commented 2 years ago

I could try to implement this if you would like.

webdev03 commented 2 years ago

@Accio1 Can I please be assigned?

leahcimto commented 2 years ago

@webdev03 I think that this might be a feature that needs a little more discussion before implementing it, including why it's useful, and the steps we plan taking to implement it, and other details (like what api to use, would the list of helpers on the page be hardcoded, etc.).

Accio1 commented 2 years ago

@FunctionalMetatable are you still interested in implementing this? It hasn't had much discussion in a while but if you are still interested in it then the discussion could probably be revived.

One thing that I am concerned about is that this could encourage post grinding/farming just to move past other Forum Helpers in the rankings. The point of The Forum Helpers is to provide others with quality help on the forums, not just to post unnecessarily to boost a post count, so we wouldn't want to add this if it would seem to be encouraging that.

Weredime commented 2 years ago

@Accio1 I think the API should be implemented with the tfh dashboard.

I am @FunctionalMetatable (its literally everywhere on my old profile)