search

themeskult / wp-svbtle

Wordpress Admin & Theme inspired by Svbtle
http://wp-svbtle.com
1.45k stars 220 forks source link

[NEW] Sidebar comments per paragraph like at medium.com #159

Closed avocade closed 11 years ago

avocade commented 11 years ago

Would be great to have comments to the right of individual paragraphs, making them more contextual and interesting:

https://medium.com/about/5972c72b18f2

dasrecht commented 11 years ago

phew :) i guess this one will be hard to archieve with the default behaviour.

but probably we could extend the comment with the paragraph "id"

but what happens if someone adds a paragraph after the users already added some comments?

Akamaozu commented 11 years ago

This would be a total departure from Svbtle theme (and Wordpress in general) but it would be a totally welcome change, in my books. Not everyone might agree, so it would be nice to be able to choose what style of comment rendering you'd prefer.

avocade commented 11 years ago

Yeah, perhaps this warrants looking a bit closer at the medium source to figure out how they did it. Perhaps giving each <p> a unique ID? But what about removing that paragraph later, should it remove the notes too or just move them to a separate place?

Akamazou: Must be configurable (and non-default) of course.

Akamaozu commented 11 years ago

Also, what happens when you move a paragraph around or edit it ... what's the best way to correctly track these changes?

ihorvorotnov commented 10 years ago

Hey everyone. I was looking for the Medium-like comments solution and found this: https://github.com/pommiegranit/paragraph_commenting

Hope it helps. Testing it right now.

kevinweber commented 10 years ago

A very easy-to-use solution for WordPress users is my plugin »Inline Comments«: www.kevinw.de/inline-comments. It's available for free on WordPress.org.