thenineteen / Semiology-Visualisation-Tool

Data driven 3D brain visualisation of semiology. Semiology to anatomy translator based on over 4600 patients from 309 peer-reviewed articles.
MIT License
9 stars 6 forks source link

Bayesian combine semiologies: how to #225

Closed thenineteen closed 3 years ago

thenineteen commented 3 years ago

When using the Bayesian method with multiple semiologies, we can do the following:

  1. treat each dataset separately. This is what is done in #222 . Concretely, using the SS dataset, it combines the semiologies (e.g. inverse variance) then using posterior-TS it combines the semiologies (using inverse variance), then takes the mean of the two estimates.

  2. Instead, integrate the SS and posterior-TS estimates per semiology first, then combine semiologies using inverse variances.

Could argue for both: the second method gives a single estimate for each semiology, then combines. The first method queries each database separately for all the semiologies, then combines the results at the end.

Which is best?

thenineteen commented 3 years ago
  1. give the same combining semiology options to Bayesian-TS data and SS data integration, as SS each have individually:
    • inverse variance with marginal probabilities or data-query estimates for variances
    • equal weights/mean,