thetwom / Tuner

Tuner app
GNU General Public License v3.0
192 stars 16 forks source link

pure tone #55

Open RustoMCSpit opened 1 year ago

RustoMCSpit commented 1 year ago

option to press a note and have it ring out a pure tone of that notw

thetwom commented 1 year ago

Thanks for the suggestion. Thought about this before, but decided not for go for it for now.

RustoMCSpit commented 1 year ago

Thanks for the suggestion. Thought about this before, but decided not for go for it for now.

why not

RustoMCSpit commented 1 year ago

?

thetwom commented 1 year ago

Sorry, for missing a better description. Implemention such a feature requires quite some efforts:

vocna commented 12 months ago

From #64

Please add tone/tuning fork feature. I think, the UI for that could be, when user click tone, then that tone play.

1 2
Screenshot_20231006-153850__01__01__01 Screenshot_20231006-153844__01__01
vocna commented 12 months ago

Find a good UI, which does not distract, and is consistent with the rest.

What do you think about my idea of the UI above? I think it's very consistent.

And it is a bit reverse of a tuner: instead of recording sound, it plays sound, so it feels a bit off-topic.

I can't see this. Tuning with own ears are very common task and belongs to tuners. It's e.g. making tuning quicker. Almost every tuner has this feature and this is the major flaw of this tuner.

Also, I think tuner is not only for tuning. It's tool for all pitch/note tasks. You can monitor and check major notes of song with it, you can train your ears with it and so on... pretty much every pitch things...

I still understand that this might be helpful for a tuner since it can help to find the correct tone quicker. But compared to the required additional code, I prefer putting the time in other things. At least at the moment :-).

I hope you can reconsider this a bit.