search

thkl / homebridge-homematic

Homematic plugin for homebridge: https://github.com/nfarina/homebridge
180 stars 49 forks source link

Falscher Status durch HomeMaticHomeKitGarageDoorService vs HomeMaticCacheManager #608

Closed gorbi2001 closed 2 years ago

gorbi2001 commented 4 years ago

Hallo Thomas,

ich habe einen GDS eingerichtet mit einem HmIP-SWDM-B2 als CLOSE Sensor und einem HmIP-WGC Garagentaster. Funktion OK, Anzeige nicht. Tor immer geschlossen. Während dem Öffnen zeigt HomeKit zwar "Wird geöffnet" an, danach aber wieder "Geschlossen"

Mein Setup: v0.1.231 "services": [ { "type": "HM-THKL-GARAGEDOOR", "service": "HomeMaticHomeKitGarageDoorService" } ] , "special": [ {
"name" : "Garage",
"type" : "HM-THKL-GARAGEDOOR",
"parameter" : {
"address_sensor_close": "HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE", "state_sensor_close": 0,
"address_actor_open": "HmIP-RF.00131A499B8D11:3.STATE",
"message_actor_open": {"on":true,"off":false},
"delay_actor_open" :1
} }

Datenpunkte:

Als Grund konnte ich Cache Eintrag für den CLOSE Sensor ausmachen. Dieser wird wie es aussieht nur beim Start der Homebridge gesetzt und später immer wieder verwendet. **_Tor geschlossen >> State 0 >> OK_** 5/26/2020, 5:33:06 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] One sensor mode. Fetching value for Close Sensor **HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE** [5/26/2020, 5:33:06 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:33:06 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:33:06 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:33:06 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE **[5/26/2020, 5:33:06 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] hit on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE 0** [5/26/2020, 5:33:37 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage door requery sensors ... [5/26/2020, 5:33:37 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:33:37 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:33:37 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:33:37 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE **[5/26/2020, 5:33:37 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] hit on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE 0** [5/26/2020, 5:33:37 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] result for close sensor 0 **_Tor geöffnet >> State 0 aus cache >> Falsch_** [5/26/2020, 5:35:47 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:35:47 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:35:47 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:35:47 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE **[5/26/2020, 5:35:47 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] hit on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE 0** [5/26/2020, 5:35:47 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] get close value result is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:35:47 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] values match close state Ab hier ohne Cache durch Änderung der HomeMaticCacheManager.js Rückgabewert immer undefined HomeMaticCacheManager.prototype.getValue = function (address) { let cv = this.cache[address] if (cv) { this.log.debug('[Cache] hit on %s %s', address, cv) // return cv **return undefined** } else { this.log.debug('[Cache] fail on %s', address) return undefined } **_Zustand: Tor geschlossen >> Cache leer >> failed >> State 0 >> OK_** [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] One sensor mode. Fetching value for Close Sensor HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] fail on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] cache failed for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE will transfer request to rega **[5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] rega result for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE is 0** [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] write 0 for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] get close value result is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] values match close state [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint STATE [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] cache .STATE (0) [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] datapointEvent STATE with 0 channel HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1 [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage event CH:HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1|DP:STATE|NV:0|TCS:false [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] One Sensor Mode Close is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] is sensor Close Event [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] Check 0 (string) will match StateSensorClose 0 (number) - true [5/26/2020, 5:38:20 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] Close sensor hm value is 0 set targetDoorState 1 [5/26/2020, 5:38:21 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] timer fired close sensor hm value is 0 set new current state 1 **_Zustand Tor geöffnet >> cache failed erzwungen >> rega >> State 1 >> Korrekt._** [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage door requery sensors ... [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] **hit on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE 0** [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] cache failed for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE will transfer request to rega **[5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] rega result for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE is 1** [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] write 1 for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] result for close sensor 1 [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint STATE [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] cache .STATE (1) [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] datapointEvent STATE with 1 channel HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1 [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage event CH:HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1|DP:STATE|NV:1|TCS:false [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] One Sensor Mode Close is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] is sensor Close Event [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] Check 1 (string) will match StateSensorClose 0 (number) - false [5/26/2020, 5:39:35 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] Close sensor hm value is 1 set targetDoorState 0 [5/26/2020, 5:39:36 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] timer fired close sensor hm value is 1 set new current state 0 **_Tor geschlossen >> cache failed erzwungen >> rega >> State 0 >> Korrekt._** [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage door requery sensors ... [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE **[5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] hit on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE 1** [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] cache failed for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE will transfer request to rega **[5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] rega result for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE is 0** [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] write 0 for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] result for close sensor 0 [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint STATE [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] cache .STATE (0) [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] datapointEvent STATE with 0 channel HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1 [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage event CH:HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1|DP:STATE|NV:0|TCS:false [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] One Sensor Mode Close is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] is sensor Close Event [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] Check 0 (string) will match StateSensorClose 0 (number) - true [5/26/2020, 5:40:17 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] Close sensor hm value is 0 set targetDoorState 1 [5/26/2020, 5:40:18 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] timer fired close sensor hm value is 0 set new current state 1 **_Tor geöffnet >> cache failed erzwungen >> rega >> State 1 >> Korrekt._** [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage door requery sensors ... [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] hit on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE 0 [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] cache failed for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE will transfer request to rega [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] rega result for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE is 1 [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] write 1 for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] result for close sensor 1 [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint STATE [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] cache .STATE (1) [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] datapointEvent STATE with 1 channel HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1 [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage event CH:HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1|DP:STATE|NV:1|TCS:false [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] One Sensor Mode Close is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] is sensor Close Event [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] Check 1 (string) will match StateSensorClose 0 (number) - false [5/26/2020, 5:41:32 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] Close sensor hm value is 1 set targetDoorState 0 [5/26/2020, 5:41:33 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] timer fired close sensor hm value is 1 set new current state 0 **_Tor geschlossen >> cache failed erzwungen >> rega >> State 0 >> Korrekt_** [[5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage door requery sensors ... [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] remove :HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] getValue (HmIP-RF) HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] check cache HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] hit on HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE 1 [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] cache failed for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE will transfer request to rega [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Core] rega result for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Cache] write 0 for HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1.STATE [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] result for close sensor 0 [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] transformDatapoint STATE [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] cache .STATE (0) [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [Generic] datapointEvent STATE with 0 channel HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1 [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] garage event CH:HmIP-RF.0015599393F1CA:1|DP:STATE|NV:0|TCS:false [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] One Sensor Mode Close is 0 [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] is sensor Close Event [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] Check 0 (string) will match StateSensorClose 0 (number) - true [5/26/2020, 5:42:44 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] Close sensor hm value is 0 set targetDoorState 1 [5/26/2020, 5:42:45 PM] [HomeMatic Produktiv] [GDS] timer fired close sensor hm value is 0 set new current state 1 Ohne Cache also alles korrekt. Den Cache abzuklemmen ist ja nur ein Quick&Dirty Workaround. Könnte man ggf drüber nachdenken den Cache für bestimmte Sensoren über die Config zu deaktivieren? xxxx_sensor_cache=false oder sowas ? Für sicherheitsrelevante Sensoren macht das sicher Sinn. Gruß Norbert
gorbi2001 commented 4 years ago

Für mich erstmal obsolete da ich mir heute das hap-homematic Addon installiert habe, kann aber gerne noch testen wenn nötig.

Gruss Norbert

stale[bot] commented 3 years ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.