thomasvs / morituri

For those about to RIP - a Unix CD ripper preferring accuracy over speed
GNU General Public License v3.0
301 stars 42 forks source link

Rip / Verify AcurrateRip Inconsistency #142

Open korndog opened 9 years ago

korndog commented 9 years ago

One of my discs rips perfectly, with successful AccurateRip verification:

13 AccurateRip reponses found Track 0: unknown (not tracked) Track 1: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 169) [8b70e2ca], DB [8b70e2ca] Track 2: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 166) [b7d4aadd], DB [b7d4aadd] Track 3: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 170) [e62328dc], DB [e62328dc] Track 4: rip accurate (confidence 90 of 168) [4f74a0b4], DB [4f74a0b4] Track 5: rip accurate (confidence 93 of 165) [ed6f85fc], DB [ed6f85fc] Track 6: rip accurate (confidence 93 of 166) [0d3156e5], DB [0d3156e5] Track 7: rip accurate (confidence 93 of 166) [c32311cb], DB [c32311cb] Track 8: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 166) [8c582dcc], DB [8c582dcc] Track 9: rip accurate (confidence 95 of 162) [2a5a21ec], DB [2a5a21ec]

The full rip log is provided below. However, subsequent verification fails. The same AccurateRip checksum is calculated for each track, but different checksums are downloaded from the AccurateRip database:

$ /usr/local/morituri/bin/rip image verify Led\ Zeppelin\ -\ Definitive\ Collection\ (Disc\ 1\ of\ 12)\ -\ Led\ Zeppelin.cue Track 1: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [8b70e2ca], DB [d8683ef2] Track 2: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [b7d4aadd], DB [a3687eb6] Track 3: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [e62328dc], DB [f476ecfb] Track 4: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [4f74a0b4], DB [95ee3916] Track 5: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [ed6f85fc], DB [09ec1d74] Track 6: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [0d3156e5], DB [5eda4cf4] Track 7: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [c32311cb], DB [5fc08b56] Track 8: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [8c582dcc], DB [30f8e97c] Track 9: rip NOT accurate (max confidence 2) [2a5a21ec], DB [b21137a5]

Am I doing something wrong? Do I need to somehow point morituri at different AccurateRip checksums???

Thanks for your help!

-Korndog

Full Rip Log

$ /usr/local/morituri/bin/rip cd rip --offset=6 Checking device /dev/sr0 CDDB disc id: 7e0a8209
MusicBrainz disc id CyRTrmZYEpfFO86t1Vrd7Q6hMcc- MusicBrainz lookup URL http://mm.musicbrainz.org/bare/cdlookup.html?toc=1+9+201937+182+12640+42740+71850+100797+121412+131350+142582+163800&tracks=9&id=CyRTrmZYEpfFO86t1Vrd7Q6hMcc- Disc duration: 00:44:50.066, 9 audio tracks

Matching releases:

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Definitive Collection (Disc 1 of 12): Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:49.000 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/068634ea-8ee1-315d-84a7-85f306db7ed3 Release : 068634ea-8ee1-315d-84a7-85f306db7ed3 Type : Compilation

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/213afef1-f474-379d-9ebd-0dee46703381 Release : 213afef1-f474-379d-9ebd-0dee46703381 Type : Album

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/6166b18d-6055-38e0-886f-b265dd1a980f Release : 6166b18d-6055-38e0-886f-b265dd1a980f Type : Album

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/64c802a2-77db-3a78-8b36-edd4122f2eb2 Release : 64c802a2-77db-3a78-8b36-edd4122f2eb2 Type : Album

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/80a7b2be-7b0e-4ca8-9a7a-87f00d176e79 Release : 80a7b2be-7b0e-4ca8-9a7a-87f00d176e79 Type : Album

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/98edca95-9ce3-3308-a88f-e799face0a29 Release : 98edca95-9ce3-3308-a88f-e799face0a29 Type : Album

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/9b0c3ce3-76e1-3b70-b8d0-dd716ea311f2 Release : 9b0c3ce3-76e1-3b70-b8d0-dd716ea311f2 Type : Album

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/bb7a604e-a06f-39bd-8b5d-edd31d0b3f16 Release : bb7a604e-a06f-39bd-8b5d-edd31d0b3f16 Type : Album

Artist : Led Zeppelin Title : Led Zeppelin Duration: 00:44:51.785 URL : http://musicbrainz.org/release/db51be41-c79b-3eee-9b63-74bcace8a357 Release : db51be41-c79b-3eee-9b63-74bcace8a357 Type : Album

Creating output directory /MUSIC/RIP/TEST/compilation/Led Zeppelin - Definitive Collection (Disc 1 of 12) - Led Zeppelin Found Hidden Track One Audio from frame 0 to 31 Ripping track 0 of 9: 00. Led Zeppelin - Hidden Track One Audio.flac Checksums match for track 0
Peak level: 0.96 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 1 of 9: 01. Led Zeppelin - Good Times Bad Times.flac Checksums match for track 1
Peak level: 100.00 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 2 of 9: 02. Led Zeppelin - Babe I'm Gonna Leave You.flac Checksums match for track 2
Peak level: 99.92 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 3 of 9: 03. Led Zeppelin - You Shook Me.flac Checksums match for track 3
Peak level: 99.33 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 4 of 9: 04. Led Zeppelin - Dazed and Confused.flac Checksums match for track 4
Peak level: 100.00 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 5 of 9: 05. Led Zeppelin - Your Time Is Gonna Come.flac Checksums match for track 5
Peak level: 90.68 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 6 of 9: 06. Led Zeppelin - Black Mountain Side.flac Checksums match for track 6
Peak level: 72.58 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 7 of 9: 07. Led Zeppelin - Communication Breakdown.flac Checksums match for track 7
Peak level: 100.00 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 8 of 9: 08. Led Zeppelin - I Can't Quit You Baby.flac Checksums match for track 8
Peak level: 100.00 % Rip quality: 100.00 % Ripping track 9 of 9: 09. Led Zeppelin - How Many More Times.flac Checksums match for track 9
Peak level: 100.00 % Rip quality: 100.00 % AccurateRip URL http://www.accuraterip.com/accuraterip/e/8/2/dBAR-009-000f128e-006e2715-7e0a8209.bin 13 AccurateRip reponses found Track 0: unknown (not tracked)
Track 1: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 169) [8b70e2ca], DB [8b70e2ca] Track 2: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 166) [b7d4aadd], DB [b7d4aadd] Track 3: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 170) [e62328dc], DB [e62328dc] Track 4: rip accurate (confidence 90 of 168) [4f74a0b4], DB [4f74a0b4] Track 5: rip accurate (confidence 93 of 165) [ed6f85fc], DB [ed6f85fc] Track 6: rip accurate (confidence 93 of 166) [0d3156e5], DB [0d3156e5] Track 7: rip accurate (confidence 93 of 166) [c32311cb], DB [c32311cb] Track 8: rip accurate (confidence 94 of 166) [8c582dcc], DB [8c582dcc] Track 9: rip accurate (confidence 95 of 162) [2a5a21ec], DB [2a5a21ec]

x37v commented 7 years ago

I just ripped the same CD 2 times. This is a brand new CD, I had never played it before this ripping session. And I got the same rip NOT accurate values each time. This is after I did my drive offset and cache setting check as indicated in the readme. I also verified the offset setting with the accuraterip db. I've attached the log file as a .txt file because github doesn't support .log Bruce Gilbert and Beaconsfield ArtWorks - Diluvial.txt

rip 0.2.3.1