thomasvs / morituri

For those about to RIP - a Unix CD ripper preferring accuracy over speed
GNU General Public License v3.0
301 stars 42 forks source link

Use Release level MusicBrainz data instead of Recording level and don't resolve Artist Credits #80

Open Freso opened 10 years ago

Freso commented 10 years ago

Right now morituri will use the metadata from Recordings on a release instead of the metadata from the Release entity. IIRC, morituri also resolves artist credits. This is what in turn results in issues such as issue #48 (which you might argue this is a duplicate of).

Some examples of non-classical releases where some their tracklists have different information than their recordings: https://musicbrainz.org/release/586d51b4-d20a-43e1-ad39-54d0ecd01933 ("(album version)" on the tracklist, not on the recording) https://musicbrainz.org/release/da93598f-fa1c-4d3f-9b9f-bcf4148c5c3a (they're all performed by "Gramsespektrum", but some of the tracks/recording are credited to them in different ways "Kontrollørene", "Word-Ski-Love", etc.)

In general, the tracklists are as close to the ones on the given release, and are probably what will be wanted. As long as the MBIDs are stored as well, it is easy to look up more in-depth information about what's going on.