Open s-areal opened 2 months ago
Also I think it's worth asking, why change ygg_ip
to planetary_ip
in the first place? If we continue with a notion of "planetary network", it would probably not involve Yggdrasil since we are now developing Mycelium as a replacement.
Also I think it's worth asking, why change
ygg_ip
toplanetary_ip
in the first place? If we continue with a notion of "planetary network", it would probably not involve Yggdrasil since we are now developing Mycelium as a replacement.
Mycelium is developed along with yggdrasil and the plan is still to support both
Mycelium is developed along with yggdrasil and the plan is still to support both
I know we're not planning to drop support for Yggdrasil. I'm just saying that with Mycelium in play it no longer makes sense to give a special name to Yggdrasil in the context of the ThreeFold network. Calling it "Planetary Network" has always been a source of confusion anyway. Changing it here will only cause more confusion, and force people to update their main.tf
files. So what's the upside?
Mycelium is developed along with yggdrasil and the plan is still to support both
I agree it's important to keep the support of both.
The project mycelium states clearly in the book that it's the "planetary network":
So I guess to the minimum planetary should now be addressed for mycelium and yggdrasil should be yggdrasil and nothing more
That being said, I do agree with Scott that
is the simplest and clearest.
IMO, if the nomenclature is already established in the community, docs and recent codes, we should revert to ygg_ip, and add myc_ip if needed for mycelium. This will be a smooth addition and not a change to properly working nomenclature, while being natural to users.
So I propose this, we don't use planetary as it's misleading. We go with this:
@xmonader does the following make sense to you?
It'd be way easier to understand.
I have multiple VM running for months now.
I realized some random ygg ip addresses are lacking on terraform output:
ygg_ip_1410 = "" ygg_ip_1413 = "" ygg_ip_1458 = "302:f959:4b26:b3dc:f5bb:9fc3:7bef:b2fc" ygg_ip_1554 = "" ygg_ip_1591 = "" ygg_ip_1598 = "300:1d67:64f1:941b:6b49:4c14:60e9:49ea" ygg_ip_1609 = "" ygg_ip_1675 = "301:8b73:6e74:709d:20b8:1940:ca8b:d218"
This never, ever happened before.
how can I output now, after ygg_ip changed to planetary_ip all the addresses of the VMs I am running?
I've tried changing the ygg_ip to planetary_ip on main.tf but i got this error message:
Error: Unsupported attribute │ │ on main.tf line 2290, in output "Planetary_ip_1394": │ 2290: value = grid_deployment._1394.vms[0].planetary_ip │ │ This object has no argument, nested block, or exported attribute named "planetary_ip".