Closed monica-thunderbird closed 4 months ago
tl;dr not sure we can fix this. It seems like an MS issue not a Thunderbird issue. Willing as always to be proven wrong :-) !
OAuth2
(TB autoconfig set it to Normal password
hooray for microsoft lack of clarity :-) (i tested on Windows 11, Ubuntu and macOS all with the same results)
Mozilla is working to resolve the problem. Presumably, Thunderbird needs a new OAuth setup with advanced MFA support. In the meantime, Thunderbird users must go down a circuitous route to receive emails from their Outlook, Hotmail, and Live inboxes. The steps are outlined in a [Mozilla support post](https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/microsoft-oauth-authentication-and-thunderbird-202) and in several [Reddit threads](https://www.reddit.com/r/Thunderbird/comments/19fevs6/finally_found_the_fix_for_this_msft_email_issue/), but we'll give you the gist of it here.
<-- I respectfullly disagree. I don't think we need to fix anything in Thunderbird nor do users need to generate an App Password but I could be wrong.Unfortunately, this story is accompanied by an additional problem. Several email clients, including Thunderbird and the official Outlook app, cannot maintain a connection with Microsoft's email services. Logging in with an App Password works, but the account randomly disconnects. Microsoft is [investigating](https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/outlook-and-other-apps-are-unable-to-connect-to-outlook-com-f4202ebf-89c6-4a8a-bec3-3d60cf7deaef) the issue and explicitly mentions Thunderbird in its support post.
<-- I cannot reproduce this. Logging in with the outlook.com password, i.e. not the App Password works and I have had no issues with random disconnects in Thunderbird in my testingWould it also help to add that users may need to enable cookies in Thunderbird settings to be sure that these changes persist, since there is a strong non-zero probability that a fair number of users do not have cookies enabled? a graphic to show the setting enabled might be helpful as well.
Would it also help to add that users may need to enable cookies in Thunderbird settings to be sure that these changes persist, since there is a strong non-zero probability that a fair number of users do not have cookies enabled? a graphic to show the setting enabled might be helpful as well.
- I added this to the checklist in comment 0:
Cookies must be set to ON in default browser e.g. Firefox or Chrome
. Please let me know if I am missing any nuances here @monica-thunderbird !
The following were fixed in revision 275525
Ready for Localization
. If not please create another revision or leave a comment here or on Matrix.{note}
to {warning}
and fixed some typos https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/microsoft-oauth-authentication-and-thunderbird-202/revision/275603@christ1 also helped! thanks, closing for real this time!
MS official site, Press and other 3rd party links
Description of the problem and solutions
See also question SUMO Question 1437606: Thunderbird conflict with Hotmail
In this KB article (https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/microsoft-oauth-authentication-and-thunderbird-202) there is no clear description of how to switch the password method from![2023-07-05-16-02-16-e0a70f](https://github.com/thunderbird/knowledgebase-issues/assets/152316395/09e19e01-bbaa-4d79-9362-18138654c79e)
Normal password
toOAuth2
in Thunderbird. There is a screencap is this SUMO article of someone who successfully did this, also copied below, (https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1417298#answer-1588949) which it would likely be helpful to replicate. I think this, along with an updated date of January 2024, would help users with this issue.[x] On the Hotmail/Outlook side: 2 step verification must be on. See MS KB Article: How to use two-step verification with your Microsoft account
[x] Cookies must be set to ON in Thunderbird
default browser e.g. Firefox or Chrome[x] On the TB side: Thunderbird account settings for the outlook.com/hotmail account IMAP must be set to
OAuth2
AND notPassword
[x]
On the TB side: you may have to change SMTP to<-- update looks like all you have to do is change it toOAuth2
and use an application specific password as well: See Microsoft KB article: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/account-billing/using-app-passwords-with-apps-that-don-t-support-two-step-verification-5896ed9b-4263-e681-128a-a6f2979a7944OAuth2
for both SMTP and IMAP[x] add screenshots
[x] add an SMTP screenshot
[x] add a note re: hat due to MS's "diversity" :-) of servers and deployments that there is no definitive solution/workaround and that TB could be broken again by MS at any time at any server in the field due to A/B testing and other stuff
[x] add TOC
[x] fix formatting to make it simpler