search

thunlp / TAADpapers

Must-read Papers on Textual Adversarial Attack and Defense
MIT License
1.51k stars 195 forks source link

Reference counter #32

Open akirataguchi115 opened 2 years ago

akirataguchi115 commented 2 years ago

It would be nice to see the reference amount on each paper. This could be picked from f.ex. scholar.google.com.

yangalan123 commented 2 years ago

Good advice. May discuss it with team members. The consideration on our side is -- we do not really want to promote the atmosphere that the work with more citations is 100% better. Many things can happen behind the citation and not all of them are directly related to paper quality (also, we do not consider ourselves having the right to judge the paper quality. We rely on the peer-review system in conferences/journals to recommend papers.)

akirataguchi115 commented 2 years ago

I hear you on the citations issue as it is really a problematic way to measure quality of a paper.

However some kind of order of the papers in this repo is already chosen. That is publication date which itself doesn't guarantee quality either (newer being better). So even if we didn't seemingly choose any order, we actually are choosing some order anyway.

yangalan123 commented 2 years ago

True, we already give some ordering by giving chronological order. We will discuss whether to put citation numbers. Btw, can you draft a PR that adds the reference number? just to give us a sense how what would you expect it would look like -- you can only add reference numbers to a few papers.

akirataguchi115 commented 2 years ago

Excellent idea. I'll draft a PR about this if I have time. Otherwise this issue is a good invitation for anyone else to do that draft too.