search

tiann / KernelSU

A Kernel based root solution for Android
https://kernelsu.org
GNU General Public License v3.0
9.79k stars 1.59k forks source link

Payback app detects root #1328

Closed meiser79 closed 7 months ago

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

Please check before submitting an issue

Describe the bug

The Payback app version 24.01.1800 detects root and just a message about an insecure environment.

May I ask you to have a look how it does the detection? Uninstalling the manager app or clearing app data/cache do not solve the issue.

Thanks a lot, meiser

To Reproduce

  1. Install the app
  2. See the message about insecure environment

Expected behavior

No response

Screenshots

No response

Logs

No response

Device info

Additional context

No response

tiann commented 7 months ago

Uninstall all modules and try again.

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

Still the same. I disabled the modules instead of uninstalling, but this should be the same, right?

pckotzer commented 7 months ago

Did yout tried it without kernelSU? It may be a Rom problem. Try with stock boot.img

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

It's not custom ROM related as it works with previous Payback version 23.11.1403. Just the update to version 24.01.1800 triggers the root detection.

pckotzer commented 7 months ago

Did you tryed stock kernel. If you compile kernel by yourself try without localversion in defconfig. Google ban now various kernel names including crdroid in kernel name or other popular kernel names like lineageos or whatever is used. What does your localversion or kernel name show?

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

Sorry, but your comments are not helpful. If you read my bug report carefully, you would see the link to the used kernel tree. There, you could have checked that the LOCALVERSION is "~InfiniR_Alioth_v2.87". BTW, I do pass Google PI with device integrity. I assume, the Payback app does not use PI for root detection, but something different.

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

Am I right that any app can find KernelSU by just checking "mount". There are KSU mount names. Any chance to rename these ones?

pckotzer commented 7 months ago

Try do do backup of data and then do clean install without a kernelsu kernel to be 100% sure

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

If I fully remove kernelsu, the app works fine.

pckotzer commented 7 months ago

Another kernel?

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

What do you mean? I recompiled the kernel tree without kernelsu. With this kernel, the app starts fine.

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

@tiann even if I uninstall all modules by renaming the modules.img, the app detects root. So it's not the mountpoint, right?

pckotzer commented 7 months ago

Perfect, thats what i wanted to hear xd

goldwoods2005 commented 7 months ago

Same as the bank app Vietbank https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vnpay.vietbank

Ksu with no module install, lastest version of the app find root Change the kernel without ksu, app start normally Still not find a way to bypass this app

ToucH9000 commented 7 months ago

Same as the bank app Vietbank https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vnpay.vietbank

Ksu with no module install, lastest version of the app find root Change the kernel without ksu, app start normally Still not find a way to bypass this app

same here

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

Thanks so much! I really appreciate your work! I verified that it works with this commit.

Niemandausduisburg commented 7 months ago

@meiser79 How you get latest Payback working? I picked this commit and it doesn't work for me. Only downgrade Payback seems to be help.

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

@Niemandausduisburg You have to either freeze the manager app with e.g. Ice Box or deinstall it.

Niemandausduisburg commented 7 months ago

@meiser79 Don't work for me

meiser79 commented 7 months ago

You might be right, I just got a broken Payback app again. It seems that KernelSU_v0.7.6-55-g20c19d7_11513-release.apk broke it again, but KernelSU_v0.7.6-51-gabf0dac_11509-release.apk works fine.

Which version do you run exactly (kernel and app)?

Niemandausduisburg commented 7 months ago

Screenshot_20240219-064049_KernelSU @meiser79

Niemandausduisburg commented 7 months ago

@meiser79 The issue isn't KernelSU. Payback is looking if you have unlocked your bootloader (custom ROM).

sd535682 commented 6 months ago

@meiser79 The issue isn't KernelSU. Payback is looking if you have unlocked your bootloader (custom ROM).

I guess no. I was using the def KSU kernel on my device. After flashing any module the Yono app crashes. If there was an issue with unlocked BL it would have been detected earlier.

sd535682 commented 6 months ago

You might be right, I just got a broken Payback app again. It seems that KernelSU_v0.7.6-55-g20c19d7_11513-release.apk broke it again, but KernelSU_v0.7.6-51-gabf0dac_11509-release.apk works fine.

Which version do you run exactly (kernel and app)?

have you tried Shamiko?

hummermann87 commented 4 months ago

You might be right, I just got a broken Payback app again. It seems that KernelSU_v0.7.6-55-g20c19d7_11513-release.apk broke it again, but KernelSU_v0.7.6-51-gabf0dac_11509-release.apk works fine. Which version do you run exactly (kernel and app)?

have you tried Shamiko?

Shamiko user here, doesn't work on LineageOS 20. :(

hummermann87 commented 4 months ago

You might be right, I just got a broken Payback app again. It seems that KernelSU_v0.7.6-55-g20c19d7_11513-release.apk broke it again, but KernelSU_v0.7.6-51-gabf0dac_11509-release.apk works fine. Which version do you run exactly (kernel and app)?

have you tried Shamiko?

Shamiko user here, doesn't work on LineageOS 20. :(

It finally works! I have used the module posted here: https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Alt-Repo/ezme-nodebug/issues/1

meiser79 commented 4 months ago

Latest Payback app (version 24.04.2501) detects root running KernelSU version 11848.

Payback app version 24.04.1101 is the latest working version.

Niemandausduisburg commented 4 months ago

Latest Payback app (version 24.04.2501) detects root running KernelSU version 11848.

Payback app version 24.04.1101 is the latest working version.

I have the same issue. Payback was working fine before update playcurl

meiser79 commented 4 months ago

Got it working by using a different app to freeze/hide the manager app.

Niemandausduisburg commented 4 months ago

Got it working by using a different app to freeze/hide the manager app.

Which app do you use to hide/freeze the manager? I tried Icebox without any luck

sevbest commented 3 months ago

Got it working by using a different app to freeze/hide the manager app.

@meiser79 if you dont mind, which app did you use to hide kernelsu ?

meiser79 commented 3 months ago

@sevbest If I mentioned it here, it would maybe stop working soon. Sorry!

sevbest commented 3 months ago

I found one that works !

Niemandausduisburg commented 3 months ago

@sevbest Which app did you found for hide KernelSU? Still fighting with to get Payback working.

justinh998 commented 2 months ago

You might be right, I just got a broken Payback app again. It seems that KernelSU_v0.7.6-55-g20c19d7_11513-release.apk broke it again, but KernelSU_v0.7.6-51-gabf0dac_11509-release.apk works fine. Which version do you run exactly (kernel and app)?

have you tried Shamiko?

Shamiko user here, doesn't work on LineageOS 20. :(

It finally works! I have used the module posted here: https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Alt-Repo/ezme-nodebug/issues/1

Does it still work for you ? I flashed the zip in your Linked therd in kernelsu and payback still doesnt work.

Niemandausduisburg commented 2 months ago

@justinh998 Payback still broken for me. I tried many things to get it working. All other apps are working fine.

pckotzer commented 1 month ago

@Niemandausduisburg did you tried to delete the KernelSU app and then try again?

Niemandausduisburg commented 1 month ago

@pckotzer Yes Payback is still crashing for me

NCLnclNCL commented 1 month ago

reset-los-props.zip Use this to hide LOS