search

tigase / beagle-im

(M) XMPP client for macOS based on TigaseSwift XMPP library
GNU General Public License v3.0
181 stars 21 forks source link

Reproducing audio bug #146

Open afa7789 opened 1 year ago

afa7789 commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug When I click on the play button of an audio nothing happens.

I can only reproduc audio by clicking on it, and it opens apple music is that right ? To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Send an audio to someone
  2. try to play it

Expected behavior

click on play button and listen to it.

Screenshots If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem. https://github.com/tigase/beagle-im/assets/26887703/eb26123e-ee28-4662-95ad-38dc6701e29b

Desktop (please complete the following information):

Additional context Is this the correct behavior ?

hantu85 commented 1 year ago

What is the macOS version that you are using? On macOS Ventura it correctly plays the file directly in Beagle IM.

afa7789 commented 1 year ago

@hantu85 I installed it with brew + cask, could it be it ?

Ventura 13.4

Maybe I need to give a permission, something like that ?

hantu85 commented 1 year ago

No, that would not cause this issue. But now, as I've rewatched your screen capture I understand what is happening.

You did not click on the 'play' button, but on 'open' button, and open action should open received audio file in the installed on the device audio player - and that is done. However Apple Music fails to play - why? Only Apple knows.

To play audio file in Beagle, click on round button with triangle one the right side. Only clicking in this area will play the file.

afa7789 commented 1 year ago

Nono, I clicked on the round button (play ) with triangle, sometimes, and after that I clicked on the file.

I could reproduce other sources of audio, but it was audios that the client downloaded from other sources, or sent to me.

I could thin down the problem to: IF I send the audio, I can't play it, but If I receive the audio, or sent from other clients it count as downloaded and I can play it.

hantu85 commented 1 year ago

I think that the file (after being sent) is lost so Beagle is unable to play it and Apple Music as well (as it cannot find a file). I'll look into that.

afa7789 commented 1 year ago

okay.

but apple music could find the file.

hantu85 commented 1 year ago

If Apple Music could find the file then Beagle IM exposing this file should as well. Moreover, the code for playing incoming and outgoing messages is the same, so I do not have any ideas why this would randomly not work.

afa7789 commented 1 year ago

@hantu85 , is there a way we can go over this together ? I can share screen, or even try to build it locally and we pair programn, I believe this is worth looking into . since it's "the best" xmpp messenger for Mac.