search

timescale / helm-charts

Configuration and Documentation to run TimescaleDB in your Kubernetes cluster
Apache License 2.0
264 stars 223 forks source link

[ISSUE] For multinode setup repository and image needs to be updated ? #385

Closed iliyas-patel-git closed 2 years ago

iliyas-patel-git commented 2 years ago

Have a look at Troubleshooting or some Common Issues

Describe the bug Repository and image in value.yaml needs to be updated to, as current installation is getting failed. image.tag=pg12.5-ts2.0.0-p0 image.repository=timescaledev/timescaledb-ha

timescaledb-kubernetes/charts/timescaledb-multinode/values.yaml

To Reproduce helm upgrade --install my-release .

Expected behavior Installation was successful using below command: helm install mnode timescaledb/timescaledb-multinode --set image.tag=pg12.5-ts2.0.0-p0 --set image.repository=timescaledev/timescaledb-ha

Deployment

paulfantom commented 2 years ago

Multinode helm chart is deprecated and not supported anymore. If you want to see this chart supported then we are looking for community maintainers - https://github.com/timescale/helm-charts/tree/master/charts/timescaledb-multinode#call-for-maintainers

realulim commented 2 years ago

Can we get some more details? I have specifically selected TimescaleDB over other Databases for its multi-node capabilities under Kubernetes. Does that mean that multi-node support will be dropped from TimescaleDB? Or is it just that the chart is deprecated and there are other ways to install a multi-node version of TimescaleDB? If yes, then how is it done?

paulfantom commented 2 years ago

I am closing this issue as TimescaleDB-Multinode helm chart is no longer maintained and deprecated. We are looking for potential community maintainers who could help us in getting that helm chart working again. If you wish to become a maintainer, please contact us on slack.

Keep in mind that TimescaleDB is not and will not be dropping multinode setup. Deprecation is only about helm chart.

realulim commented 2 years ago

For the record and for the benefit of others, who might automatically assume that "Kubernetes Support" means multinode:

I have talked to Timescale HQ and their official response was that "running TimescaleDB on a multinode Kubernetes cluster is not supported". Therefore deprecation is not only about the Helm chart.

You are correct insofar as Timescale internally runs its cloud offering on a multinode Kubernetes cluster, so technically there is a way to get it done. But it is not meant for customers.

jfaldanam commented 1 year ago

For the record and for the benefit of others, who might automatically assume that "Kubernetes Support" means multinode:

I have talked to Timescale HQ and their official response was that "running TimescaleDB on a multinode Kubernetes cluster is not supported". Therefore deprecation is not only about the Helm chart.

You are correct insofar as Timescale internally runs its cloud offering on a multinode Kubernetes cluster, so technically there is a way to get it done. But it is not meant for customers.

For other people finding this issue, I have received a different answer from the Timescale devs: https://github.com/timescale/docs/pull/2132#issuecomment-1469188674