search

tleunen / react-mdl

React Components for Material Design Lite
https://tleunen.github.io/react-mdl/
MIT License
1.76k stars 255 forks source link

Using material components web #450

Closed hankphung closed 7 years ago

hankphung commented 7 years ago

As on MDL repo:

Material Design Lite is now in limited support, with development having moved to the Material Components for the web repository.

So will we update React-mdl to use new script?

tleunen commented 7 years ago

@idancali What's your call on this?

Should we update/change name (react-mdc?) of this package? Do you prefer creating a brand new one for the new implementation, or keep react-mdl for the new implementation.

idancali commented 7 years ago

Hey guys @dannyphung @tleunen

MDL as a brand is being sunsetted as far as I can tell. It would not make much sense for us to keep onto the MDL brand if they're moving away from it.

I think it might make more sense to create a brand new one from scratch. I'm thinking something like React-Material would make more sense.

I would love to get the @react-material org but it seems taken. Not much activity there. I wonder if GitHub would be willing to let us have it to transfer @react-mdl over.

Thoughts?

tleunen commented 7 years ago

It would be awesome, indeed. Try contacting github, and the author of the org if you can find an email. I'm sure there won't be any problem.

idancali commented 7 years ago

I'm going to contact them. I did that before for other orgs and they were really cool about. I'll get back with more info once I hear back from them.

idancali commented 7 years ago

I've contacted them. I'll wait for a response and I'll keep you guys in the loop.

idancali commented 7 years ago

Hey guys, looks like GitHub thinks that the org is being used so we can't have it. We can go with something like @react-material-design perhaps.

Thoughts?

tleunen commented 7 years ago

The person who seems to own react-material is @lkarthee. I found his email from one of his commits. Wanna try sending him an email directly?

His email is his github username [at] gmail

idancali commented 7 years ago

great idea, I'll do that

idancali commented 7 years ago

@tleunen great news!

I got in touch with Kartheek @lkarthee and he is an absolutely outstanding person! Thanks so much for being so amazing about this @lkarthee

He transferred the ownership of @react-material to me so I'm now the owner of that org. I'll connect with you separately, @tleunen to talk about next steps.

Once again, many thanks @lkarthee, I really appreciate it, all the best with your startup!

hankphung commented 7 years ago

Guys, that's great! I will keep in touch and closing this issue now.

tleunen commented 7 years ago

It might also be a good idea to sync with @haoxins. He created https://github.com/haoxins/react-mdc

ghost commented 7 years ago

Hi, guys! That is so great! I can transfer react-mdc on npm if you need that 👏

Also, it's better to publish all the components as separate modules under a npm scope (such as: react-material), just as material-components-web does.

发自我的 iPhone

在 2016年12月24日，下午11:20，Tommy notifications@github.com 写道：

It might also be a good idea to sync with @haoxins. He created https://github.com/haoxins/react-mdc

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

stunaz commented 7 years ago

Hi guys, what's new with this? Maybe you guys can team up? cc @tleunen @haoxins @idancali @kradio3 @Hardtack

codekiln commented 7 years ago

This is confusing!

tleunen commented 7 years ago

React-MDL will probably not update. Unless someone else wants to take the lead and build something.