tls-attestation / draft-tls-attestation

7 stars 1 forks source link

Reframing Introduction #19

Closed muhammad-usama-sardar closed 4 months ago

muhammad-usama-sardar commented 10 months ago

The introduction section starts somewhat directly without providing any motivation why this specification is required. Here are some specific suggestions:

For instance, provide examples of the layers and one concrete implementation for each layer. Then justify the limitation of each of these existing solutions (such as RA-TLS) to clarify why this specification is required.

I think they can be removed to make the introduction more focused and concise.

The second paragraph only summarizes the general topological differences which are already presented in RFC9334. I would like to see the draft explicitly state, for instance, what is the fundamental technical difference in the specific context of this draft? And why this difference leads to a crucial difference to treat them differently?

For example, what kind of details? Maybe a couple of examples.