search

tlswg / tls13-spec

TLS 1.3 Specification
565 stars 157 forks source link

Clarify how to negotiate groups if you want to respect the client order. #1331

Closed ekr closed 9 months ago

ekr commented 9 months ago

This tries to make the situation clearer. It does add a normative SHOULD but I think it's obvious.

ekr commented 9 months ago

@davidben

ekr commented 9 months ago

The SHOULD is scoped to "servers that wish to respect the client's group preferences" anyway; it could equally well be "need to" in my opinion.

Yes, we could if we were trying to avoid 2119 language, but it seems like a circumlocution

seanturner commented 9 months ago

@kaduk Is this good-to-go from your perspective?

kaduk commented 9 months ago

@kaduk Is this good-to-go from your perspective?

Once Chris's suggestion is taken, it is okay from my perspective.

dconnolly commented 9 months ago

@kaduk Is this good-to-go from your perspective?

Once Chris's suggestion is taken, it is okay from my perspective.

Suggestion committed