toadchild / 40kdice

Statistical analysis tool for Warhammer 40,000 and Age of Sigmar
http://40k.ghostlords.com/dice/
MIT License
13 stars 7 forks source link

Anti-X isn't working and/or devastating wounds #16

Closed Calioses closed 10 months ago

Calioses commented 10 months ago

I have the data filled out for Drukhari Haywire Blasters shooting into Leman Russ's and the Anti-X and/or devastating wounds isn't being registered as the wound count is way too low. Screenshot 2024-01-28 141308

toadchild commented 10 months ago

Can you please include the URL for the roll you made, rather than just a screenshot? Thanks!

toadchild commented 10 months ago

Same config as the screenshot: https://40k.ghostlords.com/dice/#attacks=8&bs=4&ap=-1&s=3&d=3&t=11&save=2&wounds=13&wound_crit=4&wound_dev

EV: 6 wounds

With only devastating wounds (not anti-X): https://40k.ghostlords.com/dice/#attacks=8&bs=4&ap=-1&s=3&d=3&t=11&save=2&wounds=13&wound_dev

EV: 4 wounds

With only anti-X 4+ (no devastating wounds): https://40k.ghostlords.com/dice/#attacks=8&bs=4&ap=-1&s=3&d=3&t=11&save=2&wounds=13&wound_crit=4

EV: 4 wounds

With neither devastating wounds nor anti-X: https://40k.ghostlords.com/dice/#attacks=8&bs=4&ap=-1&s=3&d=3&t=11&save=2&wounds=13

EV: 0.67 wounds

toadchild commented 10 months ago

I can double check some of the math, but it appears that both devastating wounds and anti-X are individually increasing the number of wounds, and when taken together, are even more potent.

toadchild commented 10 months ago

Basic sanity check on the expected value (EV) calculations:

There doesn't appear to be a bug here, closing this issue.