search

toleda / audio_CloverALC

macOS Realtek ALC onboard audio with Clover
679 stars 109 forks source link

ALC1220 distorted sound in front green jack #114

Open johnzaro opened 7 years ago

johnzaro commented 7 years ago

I have installed the latest version of appleALC in which you have recently added audio id's 1 and 2 for the ALC1220. With audio I'd 1 the green back jack outputs audio without any issue and also the front pink jack is correctly recognized and working as a microphone. However the front green jack while being correctly recognized as headphones and auto switches between back and front green jack when I connect headphones , it outputs a very distorted and broken sound especially in lower frequencies of sound. Is there a way to fix this small issue as everything else is working perfectly fine?

toleda commented 7 years ago

Which 1220? No other 1220 user has mentioned this problem, 1220 files are the same as 1150.

johnzaro commented 7 years ago

I have a gigabyte Z270N-WiFi so it has the ALC1220 and a Bitfenix Prodigy case.

I tried using the audio id 5 from Mirone and if I unplug the back green jack for speakers and connect the front green jack for headphones (it does not support auto switch) then the audio is playing fine through headphones.

Is there anything that can be done for audio to work through headphones with Id 1 of yours as with this id I am able to auto switch where to output sound and also use my headphones mic with front pink jack?

toleda commented 7 years ago

Support for 1220/Audio IDs: 1 or 2 only.

johnzaro commented 7 years ago

Support for ID 1 is what I am asking for

toleda commented 7 years ago

1220/Audio ID: 1 and 2/Headphone switching supported. If Headphones/Front/Green connected and SysPref/Sound/Output says Internal Speakers; hardware problem, connector or cable.

malhal commented 7 years ago

Same problem here with GA-H270 Gaming 3 and Corsair 330R case using 2 different audio patch techniques. I think it probably is a hardware issue as I read on windows forums people having to RMA the front ports because of grounding issues. It is strange you have a different case though.

I'll be testing audio_CloverALC 1220 and if successful I can update the Readme adding 1220 to the list of supported chips. Obviously the scrambled audio on front ports will likely remain.

toleda commented 7 years ago

ALC1220, both versions supported.

malhal commented 7 years ago

Yep was successful on my hardware, submitted PR to update Readme.

johnzaro commented 7 years ago

What do you mean?? Is there a way for the front audio to work correctly?

malhal commented 7 years ago

Sorry I hijacked your issue, I'll keep investigating the front audio because no it's not fixed, it is still garbled. If anyone else gets this issue made they could post their motherboard and case here too. By the way with headphones I hear electrical interference.

And I closed my PR because my audio has the problem where music files and videos don't play. Need to try to remember how I fixed that last time.

edit: discovered I need audio_ALCInjection and that fixed it but not sure I like the idea of AppleHDA.kext being patched since I may lose that in an update.

johnzaro commented 7 years ago

I don't think it is a hardware issue as I mentioned above that I tried using the audio id 5 from Mirone in AppleALC (which does not support auto switch between back and front green jack) so if I unplug the back green jack for speakers and connect the front green jack for headphones then the audio is playing fine through headphones. Also in windows front green jack also works fine.

Only with audio id 1 the sounds becomes corrupted and distorted.

barrrrt commented 7 years ago

I have the same problem with crackling sound with the front green jack. I use a Asus Z170 Pro Gaming (so its a 1150). Still no luck to solve the issue. Hm... i installed a clean sierra applehda -> afterwards i installed audio_cloveralc -> i did put headset into the jacks of the backside. I had no sound there. Afterwards i did another clean installation and did put it back to the front jack. Now it worked. I really don't know what was changed.

toleda commented 7 years ago

1150 off topic.
Distortion/crackling is a user system specific hardware problem. Front panel audio issues are a case/connector problem.

barrrrt commented 7 years ago

Yes, i know its a different chip. But the problem seems to be the same. @toleda do you think a driver from windows can change stuff, so that the problem occurs like described here? I just booted back to windows and back to OSX, and the problem came back.

toleda commented 7 years ago

Title of thread is 1220/front panel distortion; 1150/Win 10 ??? Win 10 does not cause macOS audio distortion Win 10 can cause macOS no audio, off topic

joseracer commented 7 years ago

Hi Toleda, thanks for your hard work. I´m experiencing the same problem (front headphone´s jack distortion.) on a Gigabyte Z270x-Gaming 5, and had the same on a Gigabyte Z270N-Gaming 5 before this one. I´ve found that the problem is only when the OS volume level is >30% only, seems this can be the Gigabyte included headphone AMP causing the issue. Will probably try a fresh install later on to see if that fixes it, but at the lower OS volume settings the distortion is not there and volume is actually loud enough, just thought it might help sharing the issue here.

Thanks again!

OSX: 10.12.6 - Gigabyte z270x Gaming 5 / i7 7700k - Nvidia GF 970GTX with web drivers.

toleda commented 7 years ago

macOS/Desktop/AppleHDA does not support external amps. Try https://github.com/RehabMan/EAPD-Codec-Commander

lobmarib commented 4 years ago

I know this is an old topic, but any progress on this? I'm experiencing the same issue (same mobo) running mojave (AppleALC only as codec commander was discontinued)

malhal commented 4 years ago

I've just been setting volume level to 1 which is still very loud and distorted but by setting volume in the app to medium and it limits most of the distortion.