search

tombonez / noTunes

A simple macOS application that will prevent iTunes or Apple Music from launching.
MIT License
3.78k stars 61 forks source link

Apple Music still opens but immediately closes, making the Dock jump #23

Open steveswinsburg opened 2 years ago

steveswinsburg commented 2 years ago

Firstly, this is great. My headphones have a touch pad on one ear to pause the music, but iTines intercepts that and decides to open. So this app kills it. Almost. I find that Music.app still opens but is then killed, and this makes the dock jump.

It may be a limitation of the listener approach in the code of your app. It seems odd that Apple allows the Dock to show the app launching but then other listeners are notifier and get a chance to interact with it and kill it I would expect the notifications to be sent before the Dock is notified).

Anyway, unsure if there is a fix, just logging it.

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/129129/150937080-49c6b0e2-f79b-47d3-9b12-7c460d7b401d.mp4

andrask commented 2 years ago

It actually gives me a good feeling that I know that the shukker Music app has been kicked in the face before it even showed up. It's a type of ASMR :)

maurymarkowitz commented 1 year ago

This is not a bug, although it might be annoying. noTunes works by watching for Music being launched and then sending it a quit notification. It has to start for noTunes to work, and that's going to bounce the dock. Annoying yes, but just part of the system.

YoniMelki commented 1 year ago

This is not a bug, although it might be annoying. noTunes works by watching for Music being launched and then sending it a quit notification. It has to start for noTunes to work, and that's going to bounce the dock. Annoying yes, but just part of the system.

@maurymarkowitz Any option to avoid the icon app bouncing in the dock?

noc2spam commented 1 year ago

Oh well, I actually love the fact that music tries to open, but it cannot. :D

I know this comment is offtopic, but thank you @tombonez for this awesome project. :)