Quiet option switch - Githubissues

trabucayre / openFPGALoader

Universal utility for programming FPGA

https://trabucayre.github.io/openFPGALoader/

Apache License 2.0

1.21k stars 258 forks source link

Quiet option switch #73

Closed eblot closed 3 years ago

eblot commented 3 years ago

Would it be possible to add a --quiet option switch so that openFPGALoader does neither emit:

= progression chars on stderr
completion %-age on stdout This would be very useful to use it in unattended context (such as CI/CD), as it generates a large amount of text which makes the output harder to parse and not useful it this kind of context.

Thanks a lot for this tool, it seems to overcome many limitations encountered with xc3sprog, it is a pity it is much harder to find for now. I hope it will soon move up in search ranks!

trabucayre commented 3 years ago

Would it be possible to add a --quiet option switch so that openFPGALoader does neither emit:
* `=` progression chars on stderr

* completion %-age on stdout
  This would be very useful to use it in unattended context (such as CI/CD), as it generates a large amount of text which makes the output harder to parse and not useful it this kind of context.
Yes of course. What is the required level of quiet (just progressBar or everything?)

Thanks a lot for this tool, it seems to overcome many limitations encountered with xc3sprog, it is a pity it is much harder to find for now. I hope it will soon move up in search ranks! Thanks! I know I need to improve my communication ... :)

eblot commented 3 years ago

It think it is ok to have the info and steps, but progression (both as bars and percentage) generates a lot of lines. I'd say, everything that requires emitting a CR / \r char :-)

I know I need to improve my communication ... :)

:-) I had a hard time finding this tool w. google, which is really a pity.

BTW, unrelated question: I'm using an Arty-A7 100T, sending the bitstream to RAM (not SPI flash). I'm a newbie with FPGAs but what does the "erase" step do when using RAM?

trabucayre commented 3 years ago

I've pushed this feature. It's okay for you ?

:-) I had a hard time finding this tool w. google, which is really a pity. I know except for twitter I haven't done anything to promote this tool (and to improve search rank)... @Martoni has done more in this topic (blog + french magazine) than me.

BTW, unrelated question: I'm using an Arty-A7 100T, sending the bitstream to RAM (not SPI flash). I'm a newbie with FPGAs but what does the "erase" step do when using RAM?

RAM must be blank before loading a new bitstream. This force the FPGA in a specific state and start with the new content.

eblot commented 3 years ago

Perfect! Thanks a lot. Thanks also for the explanation of the flashing steps.