search

treban / pimatic-tradfri

This plugin provides a tradfri interface for pimatic.
https://pimatic.org/plugins/pimatic-tradfri/
GNU General Public License v2.0
11 stars 3 forks source link

TradfriActor Wireless PIR Sensor doesn´t update status. #22

Closed scobby closed 6 years ago

scobby commented 6 years ago

Pimatic version :

pimatic version 0.9.42

Plugin version :

"pimatic-tradfri" (0.1.17)

Problem / Feature :

Wireless TradfriActor doesnt Update status. Always status active.

Expected :

Change in Status to "active" when movement detected, else disabled.

Notes

treban commented 6 years ago

@scobby Sorry, but this is not feasible.

The problem is that the tradfri gateway does not generate an event. So I can't see this. The presence status of the device only indicates that this device is online in the radio network. This also applies to the remote controls.

I'm developing a plugin that uses the deconz/raspbee/conbee zigbee modules. (35€ amazon)

This means that both the remote control and the motion sensor can be used independently. And all zigbee lights are also compatible. see here

It works very well and I want to release the plugin in a few days.

treban commented 6 years ago

I will update the readme, to make it clear

michbeck100 commented 6 years ago

Sorry to comment on the closed ticket, but i would have the same request. I've seen that some of the pimatic-tradfri devices are getting informed by using setObserver. Can't you use this for the motion sensor, too?

treban commented 6 years ago

No :( Observing the motion sensor / remotes has no effect. The gateway has the peculiarity not to send messages about sensor events. since firmware version 1.2.42 also group events aren't sent properly.