search

trias-project / daisie-checklist

🇪🇺 DAISIE - Inventory of alien species in Europe
https://trias-project.github.io/daisie-checklist/
MIT License
0 stars 2 forks source link

establishmentMeans mapping #15

Closed LienReyserhove closed 5 years ago

LienReyserhove commented 5 years ago

Information for establishmentMeans is contained in ss_species_status. This is what I suggest for the mapping to the [establishmentMeans vocabulary]():

ss_species_status establishmentMeans
Alien introduced
Cryptogenic uncertain
Naturalized naturalised
Casual naturalised
Alien_invasive invasive

I chose to map casual to naturalised, based on the argument by @timadriaens here

timadriaens commented 5 years ago

you mean naturalized to casual. I think perhaps it's best to bring them in line with Blackburn et al. as in the new darwin core proposal of @qgroom ? So naturalized to introducedNaturalised, Alien_invasive to introducedInvasive?

qgroom commented 5 years ago

Actually, in the paper we propose vagrant for casual (they are synonyms). We do maintain introducedInvasive, but we discourage people from using it, because we would prefer people use degreeOfEstablishment. We only maintain it to keep back compatibly of data on GBIF.

ss_species_status establishmentMeans
Alien introduced
Cryptogenic uncertain
Naturalized introduced
Casual vagrant
Alien_invasive introduced
DavidRoy commented 5 years ago

@LienReyserhove are we mapping to degreeOfEstablishment for DAISIE? If so, I'd be ok with this suggestion by @qgroom. If not, I would prefer your original mapping of Alien_invasive (DAISIE) to invasive (GBIF) to retain this information from DAISIE