Can't connect outside local network

codingcronus commented 5 years ago

I cannot connect two devices while one of them is outside the local network (I disable wifi and set it to 4g).

I am using the new Standard API and adding my STUN and TURN servers by:

let iceServices: TNSRTCIceServer[] = [
      new TNSRTCIceServer(['turn:{myturnipaddress}:3478'], '{myusername}', '{mypassword}'),
      new TNSRTCIceServer(['stun.l.google.com:19302']),
      new TNSRTCIceServer(['stun1.l.google.com:19302']),
      new TNSRTCIceServer(['stun2.l.google.com:19302']),
      new TNSRTCIceServer(['stun3.l.google.com:19302']),
      new TNSRTCIceServer(['stun4.l.google.com:19302'])
  ];

const options: TNSRTCConfigurationOptions = {
      iceServers: iceServices
};

const config = new TNSRTCConfiguration(options);
let connection = new TNSRTCPeerConnection(config);

// From here I use the connection...

I have tested the TURN-server using the online testing tool and it seems that it works as expected.

The connection works perfectly while running on my local network.

Which platform(s) does your issue occur on?

iOS (I have not tested Android)

Please, provide the following version numbers that your issue occurs with:

Plugin version: ^2.0.0-alpha.18 (edit: Tested with both alpha.15 and .18)

triniwiz commented 5 years ago

Can you try using only the turn also is there any way to verify you are getting connected to the turn server

triniwiz commented 5 years ago

Also what are you using to set up the call?

codingcronus commented 5 years ago

I have tried to use only the TURN server and as a matter of fact I cannot see that it connects. When I use the Trickle ICE tool I can see the request, so the TURN server is responding, but I guess the request is never send from the WebRTC library. Let me see if the "old" API is working.

I am using Socket.IO for signalling.

Thanks for a brilliant library none the less!

codingcronus commented 5 years ago

Hi Triniwiz I have verified that the configuration really ignores the ICE servers. I edited the constructor of FancyRTCConfiguration.swift where I inserted my TURN server as the only entry. After I did that, my TURN server logs shows incoming requests and the video connection is started successfully.

Please have a look at my initial source code for reference.

Also, here is the modified constructor: