triplea-game / triplea

TripleA is a turn based strategy game and board game engine, similar to Axis & Allies or Risk.
https://triplea-game.org/
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.35k stars 399 forks source link

UI Tweaks #1226

Closed DanVanAtta closed 7 years ago

DanVanAtta commented 8 years ago
Cernelius commented 8 years ago

"Export screenshot" is definitively wrong and confusing. I would say "Export Full Game Image", as "Map" makes me think I'm exporting just the map, like for printing it out as a boardgame, without the units on it etc..

Also, sometimes people want to actually export the map, to print it out; you may want to inform them they can do it by first ticking View/Show Units off.

DanVanAtta commented 8 years ago

"Game" vs "Map" has an interesting history. I think map makers know "game" very well as distinct from "map". The casual user thinks of a game as something that is taking place, while the map is more the territories and connections and initial unit allocation.

"Export Full Game Image" would then seem to render a full drawing of the map with the current unit locations.

FrostionAAA commented 8 years ago

I don’t get it. What’s wrong with Screenshot? I know it does not generate an image of JUST what is on the screen, but it is a normal word for what is happening. The user pressing this feature will find that it is a full-map screenshot eventually. Using other words would be just as confusing.

Export map image could just as well mean exporting a clone of the map zip, at least in my understanding. Game image could sound like a save game or something. What about renaming to “Export full map screenshot”? Or some other rephrasing?

It seems people have different understanding of the words and the interpreted meaning.

DanVanAtta commented 8 years ago

"Export map image could just as well mean exporting a clone of the map zip"

How so? I don't quite see it.

FrostionAAA commented 8 years ago

If “map” is understood as "the entire map" with all attached files, rules, setup and whatever, not only the graphics currently seen on screen. But again, maybe it is just a matter of perception and understanding of words.

Cernelius commented 8 years ago

Whatever sensible solution is much better than calling that thing "screenshot" or "screenview" or "screenanything". Now you can't even say that you took an actual screenshot, without anyone else thinking that you exported that thing, instead. "screenshot" should go for good, as a name. What about: "Export Full View Image"?

DanVanAtta commented 8 years ago

The feature in question also captures unit positions? "Export Map Snapshot" would work in that case if we have units too. Otherwise I still like "export map image" the best so far. "Export full View image" is not bad, but a bit unclear what is meant by "full view", and "image" of what? "Export full map image" might be better.

Cernelius commented 8 years ago

As long as screenwhatever goes.

ron-murhammer commented 8 years ago

@DanVanAtta - "network menu shows during single player games" should be fixed with #1281

ron-murhammer commented 8 years ago

@DanVanAtta - Renamed both menu options with #1282