triplea-game / triplea

TripleA is a turn based strategy game and board game engine, similar to Axis & Allies or Risk.
https://triplea-game.org/
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.29k stars 381 forks source link

2.6 The ability to load & unload ships in the Combat phase to one of your own territories. #12641

Open TheDog-GH opened 3 weeks ago

TheDog-GH commented 3 weeks ago

The amount of times I have forgotten to do this in the non Combat phase, because I have to come back to it. All other non combat movement can be done in the Combat phase except load & unload ships. We have all done this.

EDIT: Please make this a property so true or false to activate or not.

<!-- if true, allow load & unload ships in the Combat Move phase, other A&A rules could be added to this later -->
<property name="Allow a Non Combat Move in the Combat Move phase" value="true" editable="false"> <boolean/> </property>

. Project Feature Cards https://github.com/orgs/triplea-game/projects/9/views/1

asvitkine I have cheekily assigned this to you, I hope you have time to pick one of these Top requests and also to draw your attention to the above Project Feature Cards 😉

panther2 commented 3 weeks ago

We have all done this.

No, not all!

If this request is really going to be realized I strongly recommend to include this as an optional feature. It is somehow contradictory that we on the one hand try to improve rules compliance and on the other hand weaken rules compliance. I mean TripleA is more than just a gameboard where you can arbitrarily move pieces.

I hate that TripleA illegally allows NCMs during Combat move phase. But I gave up fighting against this years ago.

Not to insult anybody - just my individual opinion.

TheDog-GH commented 3 weeks ago

Not being an A&A boardgame player, I forget TripleA roots.

Yes it should be an optional rule.

Having coded 1941 GCD it is very heavily viewed, so I now appreciate your annoyance, there are 10s of thousands of A&A players.

panther2 commented 3 weeks ago

@TheDog-GH Thank you, I appreciate your understanding.

Cernelius commented 3 weeks ago

@TheDog-GH This is quite the rabbit hole. If a developer is actually intentioned to do anything about this, I can provide some insight. Let me know.