troelsbjerre / Bottleneck

Factorio mod that tell you which assemblers are starved of ingredients
Other
26 stars 21 forks source link

Adjust the dots for usability #74

Closed mybuddymichael closed 4 years ago

mybuddymichael commented 4 years ago

master

How the dots look on master

This Branch

How the dots look on this branch

Details

This branch adjusts the icons to make them more slightly more usable at a glance.

troelsbjerre commented 4 years ago

Good job. Looks much clearer. However, I can see why some people would prefer the existing graphics, so overwriting the existing is not a good option. The new graphics could be added as an alternative graphics set, just like with the small version of the signals.

mybuddymichael commented 4 years ago

Thanks for considering this!

If you have a second, can you expand on why people might prefer the existing graphics so I can consider how to best accommodate those folks?

Nexela commented 4 years ago

If you have a second, can you expand on why people might prefer the existing graphics so I can consider how to best accommodate those folks?

People hate change :)

Roang-zero1 commented 4 years ago

Goes to show I should not be a graphics designer, I really like the improved look!

Roang-zero1 commented 4 years ago

It would be easy to merge the new items into the options. All you have to do is keep the current icons. Add the new ones with a different name (e.g. altert-flat) and add them to the prototypes in https://github.com/troelsbjerre/Bottleneck/blob/master/data.lua#L60-L66 .

local icons = {
  none = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/white-flat.png",
  alert = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/alert-flat.png",
  cross = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/cross-flat.png",
  minus = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/minus-flat.png",
  pause = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/pause-flat.png",
  stop = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/stop-flat.png",
  none3D = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/white.png",
  alert3D = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/alert.png",
  cross3D = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/cross.png",
  minus3D = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/minus.png",
  pause3D = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/pause.png",
  stop3D = "__Bottleneck__/graphics/stop.png",
}
Roang-zero1 commented 4 years ago

Changes with both icon sets available at: https://github.com/Roang-zero1/Bottleneck/tree/adjust-icons

mybuddymichael commented 4 years ago

Just FYI, I haven't tested the new colors with the existing graphics.

Roang-zero1 commented 4 years ago

Just FYI, I haven't tested the new colors with the existing graphics.

I've tried them for a short while and the old items also look clearer with the new colors.